
Forum Posts: 10 | Comment #1 by Kranitoko Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:33:26 PM | |
| See. Now you guys know how to choose great winners! |
|

Forum Posts: 18 | Comment #2 by Smithman117 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:34:57 PM | |
| Why on earth is Bayonetta 3rd for game of the year? |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #3 by Webb [STAFF] Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:38:12 PM | |
| @#2 - That's why --> http://www.xbox360achievements.org/game/bayonetta/review/ =P |
|

Forum Posts: 3 | Comment #4 by PopsiclesYay Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:38:22 PM | |
| @Smithman117 Agreed. What? |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #5 by reg12365 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:41:10 PM | |
| Is it just me who hates Reach? |
|

Forum Posts: 59 | Comment #6 by The Dutch Pinyo Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:45:51 PM | |
| Finnaly a good list! Glad to see CODBLOPS isnt in here. |
|

Forum Posts: 1 | Comment #7 by Rocketman162 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:54:59 PM | |
| WHAT ON EARTH?!?!? Mass Effect for GOTY???? sorry just what? Not Halo? Not Battle Field? Not Alan Wake? Mass Effect 3rd Halo 1 Bayonetta 2 simple Other than that I could hug you guys for making the list Black Ops free everything else is spot on :) nice list other than GOTY... |
|

Forum Posts: 237 | Comment #8 by R0Y4LEwitCHEESE Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:55:14 PM | |
| @3 Because it was awesome, but not awesome enough to be 1. |
|

Forum Posts: 568 | Comment #9 by Mega Mayo Man Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 12:57:05 PM | |
Great to see Reach winning awards! Was scared it was going to be shot down like every CoD:Fanboy comment I read! Also glad to see Mass Effect 2 sweeping up a couple and Microsoft Games. Great list, great winners, great year! Here's to the next one! :) |
|

Forum Posts: 3511 | Comment #10 by jackanape Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:05:07 PM | |
| @2 Bayonetta is the shizzle, you know it deep down in your heart of hearts. So we recognised that lurking feeling and put it out there for all to see. Yay you. |
|

Forum Posts: 267 | Comment #11 by macd Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:06:18 PM | |
| ME2 got GotY from this site. Good, I didn't want to have to stop visiting. ME2 is a hell of a game. |
|

Forum Posts: 104 | Comment #12 by Laorik Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:09:11 PM | |
| Alright Bayonetta and Platinum Games. I'm in love with this company. Seems like they came out of no where. |
|

Forum Posts: 176 | Comment #13 by TheBDanAbstract Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:13:04 PM | |
| @#5, yes, it's just you. |
|

Forum Posts: 42 | Comment #14 by the_dan Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:14:12 PM | |
| alan wake best story :D |
|

Forum Posts: 56 | Comment #15 by Fyr3x Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:21:34 PM | |
| Good Choice! ME2 is my GOTY too. |
|

Forum Posts: 50 | Comment #16 by Zappa Power Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:22:51 PM | |
| Best graphics of the year... didn't go to Castlevania? Did everything pertaining to aesthetics in that game not blow anyone else away? |
|

Forum Posts: 23 | Comment #17 by darkdeath174 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:24:41 PM | |
| well with Conrad Verner there was a glitch which made it not matter what you said to him in the first game. it go with you put a gun in his face even if you didnt |
|

Forum Posts: 2082 | Comment #18 by StillTIPPIN187 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:25:58 PM | |
| Glad to see Reach and Alan Wake taking some much deserved awards. Both are seriously underrated games. |
|

Forum Posts: 50 | Comment #19 by Zappa Power Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:26:12 PM | |
| And plus, Mass Effect may be pretty, but the ridiculous stiffness of the character models' face is cringe-worthy at times. How many games is Bioware gonna make before they make character's expressions look at least a little bit more natural? |
|

Forum Posts: 45 | Comment #20 by zoopilandia Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:26:38 PM | |
| Oh my god, the trolls on this website. People of "Whatever the hell"-landia: this list is in great part a personal opinion (altough they're spot on, kudos X360A). They don't matter that much; make your own lists people! |
|

Forum Posts: 234 | Comment #21 by blurbia Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:39:27 PM | |
| I liked Dance Central. Dance Central wins New Franchise in my book. Otherwise, pretty good picks. :) |
|

Forum Posts: 25 | Comment #22 by DarthTrakd Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:41:11 PM | |
| I was a little shocked to see mass effect getting so few awards, i've never played it but from the way you guys have been going on about it i expected a clean sweep. but spot on for dissapointment of the year, SW:FU2 was a massive FU and i'm not talking about the force... |
|

Forum Posts: 3177 | Comment #23 by Capn Doug Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:48:41 PM | |
Impressive list, Webb. Can't really argue with any of the choices, plus it's nice to see that even a Mass Effect Fanboy like yourself (and me, for that matter) can realize the one or two slight drawbacks that the game had keeping it from sweeping the awards all together. Kudos for giving Bayonetta the respect it deserves, too. I picked it up when my local video store closed down and was blown away by just how smooth and polished the whole game is. Everything flows so well and is almost intuitive. You also have me looking forward to a few games that I bought on Boxing Day but haven't played yet, like Alan Wake. It really was a great year to be a gamer. |
|

Forum Posts: 417 | Comment #24 by ATCS Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 01:49:24 PM | |
| Very nice list. I enjoyed Bayonetta as well. |
|

Forum Posts: 1314 | Comment #25 by ThePumpkinKing Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 02:02:50 PM | |
| There's that Mass Effect fanboy boner of yours sticking out again. I love Mass Effect, but this list is all wrong. |
|

Forum Posts: 2693 | Comment #26 by LickableLemons7 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 02:11:49 PM | |
| Hmmm...I haven't played Bayonetta. Maybe I'll give it a try. And I still haven't gotten Mass Effect 2, and I also haven't played Mass Effect 1. I know, shame on me. I really want to give all these games a try! They look pretty vicious! Here's to 2011. |
|

Forum Posts: 443 | Comment #27 by dertswa687o Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 02:15:26 PM | |
| Looks like I'm getting Bayonetta at some point based on how much praise it seems to have gotten... and it does look fun. |
|

Forum Posts: 201 | Comment #28 by High Lord Sigma Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 02:20:20 PM | |
| @7: While all three of the titles you mentioned are excellent games, none of them have the sheer scope that Mass Effect 2 does, which I suspect is one of the reasons it took the top honor. |
|

Forum Posts: 30 | Comment #29 by gallit Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 02:20:46 PM | |
| now this is a list more to what I was thinking. Love Bayonetta and ME2. still need to get brotherhood and RDR. Looking forward to 2011 and all the new games it is going to bring. |
|

Forum Posts: 95 | Comment #30 by B Rock3232 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 02:43:48 PM | |
Halo Reach original score of the year? Its the same music it has had for every Halo game! How in the world is that original? And I don't agree at all with what you said about the Force Unleashed 2. I would think that them selling DLC for only 80 MSP and with that being able to kill all the ewoks you ever wanted, is more then enough to not win the disappointment of the year. :) |
|

Forum Posts: 1220 | Comment #31 by dirge Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 02:46:16 PM | |
| Great to see some Bayonetta loving in the list, a top class game in my opinion! |
|

Forum Posts: 26 | Comment #32 by josh785 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 03:32:20 PM | |
| Yeaaah Mass Effect! Woooo |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #33 by Tkbacon99 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 03:43:57 PM | |
| Shocked to see CoD BO not up for atleast runner up for best MP, and AC:B is a runner up. I find ACBs MP fun but I find BO funner, has more variety, and will last longer. |
|

Forum Posts: 77 | Comment #34 by ArcticOblivion Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 03:49:19 PM | |
| Glad to see "Force Unleashed 2" won "Biggest Disappointment", but it's hardly a mystery why it was so bad; the first end credit to be shown was "Julio Torres". Torres is one of those people who needs to stay far away from anything Star Wars because he will only destroy it; almost like George Lucas. |
|

Forum Posts: 99 | Comment #35 by Skeletor Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 04:05:54 PM | |
| Thought I'd see Darskiders in either 'surprise of the year' or 'New franchise of the year' categories. Either way, great and objective list. |
|

Forum Posts: 42 | Comment #36 by Quake007 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 04:11:53 PM | |
#30 Wrong. I'm ashamed to say that, while I have been bitching about getting ME and ME2 for the past year, I'm always broke when I go out and try to get it. Someday... |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #37 by Sean1234 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 04:16:21 PM | |
| ME2 and RDR were tied for GOTY in my opinion, but the more I think about it, I agree with you |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #38 by blackout529 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 04:22:22 PM | |
| I was agreeing with everything until the game of the year...Bayonetta? Really? Should've been 3. Mass Effect 2, 2. Halo: Reach, 1. Red Dead Redemption. |
|

Forum Posts: 106 | Comment #39 by bawrash Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 04:57:34 PM | |
| halo reach disappointment of the year, not because it was bad it never lived up to the hype. Transformers: war for cybertron should have been surprise of the year I was unsure when I bought it but its my GOTY. |
|

Forum Posts: 2773 | Comment #40 by jtr1gg3r Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 04:58:04 PM | |
| Great list, cant wait to see the shiny 20 anticipated video, last ears as awesome :) |
|

Forum Posts: 11 | Comment #41 by Eggy x360a Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:01:49 PM | |
| It feels like Im the only one that doesnt like Grand Theft Horse...I mean Red Dead Redemption, my mistake. |
|

Forum Posts: 493 | Comment #42 by EcT Felix Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:20:34 PM | |
| i have to cry. |
|

Forum Posts: 61 | Comment #43 by Beanovsky Durst Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:33:46 PM | |
| Nice to see a decent (as in RDR didn't win everything) list, glad that Alan Wake won best story, and Dead Rising 2 got recognized. |
|

Forum Posts: 30 | Comment #44 by Launch Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:36:46 PM | |
@30 Reach's music is vastly different to all other Halos. I'm happy enough with those rewards, Reach and Mass Effect 2 were my favourite games this year. |
|

Forum Posts: 56 | Comment #45 by HeyKnee Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:40:37 PM | |
| @42 I feel your pain. |
|

Forum Posts: 152 | Comment #46 by SnowSHOWERS Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:45:03 PM | |
| couldn't agree more with ME2, just picked it up again and played it all the way through and couldn't remember why i traded it in. |
|

Forum Posts: 87 | Comment #47 by dylanmannen Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:54:05 PM | |
Oh good!!!Webb!, have you even playd crackdown 1 and 2? they are in the same city,.. but the don't look anything alike. it was a totaly new awesome place. crackdown 2 was an awesome game. and realy,? nothing new to the game?. yeah, hellecopters, flying skill that was awesome. 4 player co-op, multiplayer ther was aloot new cool stuff for that game,.. not youst zombies.. if you liked the first, you shulld like the second. play the games befor doing fals statments about em ^^ besides that, ^ awesome list. thinks it's REALY weard that super meat boy didn't winn best arcade? but yeah. great list. cool that bayonetta is in the topp three games ^^ and btw, sry for my bad englis xD :P i hop you can reed it x) |
|

Forum Posts: 238 | Comment #48 by SuperWoody64 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 05:58:43 PM | |
I didn't think Mass effect 2 was as good as 1. I'll finish it one of these days. |
|

Forum Posts: 114 | Comment #49 by Easter Bunny 00 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 06:17:25 PM | |
| :( I just played Mass Effect 2 again because of the discounted DLC. But I have to say, I dont like it. I think fans of Mass Effect love,it, but people who just pick it up to play or people who cant get in to it dont like it so much. Basically, I dont think ME2 shouldve won. It has diehard fans, but it doesnt apply to the masses. 8/10 people I ask dont like it at all, while 2/10 think its the greatest game ever. I believe game of the year should go to a game that most everyone will enjoy. Reach maybe, but even thats a stretch. Id say Red Dead, because anybody can pick it up, play, and honestly say its a good, great, or awesome game. :/ Other than that, Go Platinum Games!!! Very underrated if I do say so myself. |
|

Forum Posts: 231 | Comment #50 by Infomouse Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 06:48:13 PM | |
Mass Effect 2 was well deserved for GOTY. Well that's it folks! We'll see you all next year when Mass Effect 3 takes GOTY! Go Mass Effect! |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #51 by blackout529 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 07:24:32 PM | |
@#47 I loved the first game, but crackdown 2 sucked. Same graphics, same bugs. A helicopter isn't enough to call it a sequel. |
|

Forum Posts: 743 | Comment #52 by l.maciver Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 07:34:15 PM | |
you must be very excited webb that mass effect is considered the best game here. I have no problem with any of the winners and runners up they where all great games. Its good to see Halo winning and mass effect too, RDR was a no brainer it deserved to win in some award and it did. HAPPY NEW YEAR EVERYONE. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #53 by Tkbacon99 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 07:44:08 PM | |
| @49 I have to agree with you man... After I played it once, I am just not intrested to play it anymore. I think GOTYs should go to a game that has a long lasting effect and that you get never sick of the game. ME2 in my opinion is not as replayable as RDR or even Fallout as both those are huge games thus more replayable and fun. Plus with RDR having a MP, it makes the game even more replayable. |
|

Forum Posts: 772 | Comment #54 by tpb Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 08:00:37 PM | |
| Good list... Dont agree with Mass Effect 2 being game of the year though... It was a good game but far far too simplified. Was an WRPG with the RPG elements striped out :(... |
|

Forum Posts: 114 | Comment #55 by Easter Bunny 00 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 08:04:28 PM | |
| @53 YES! Im glad somebody understood me! Thanks for agreeing, and yes! Either Fallout or RDR, something with replay! :D |
|

Forum Posts: 15247 | Comment #56 by Minty [STAFF] Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 09:00:34 PM | |
@50 I wouldn't give GOTY to ME3 next year just yet. I mean, Bioware themselves are putting out Dragon Age 2 which has a strong chance, as does Elder Scrolls. And that's just the action/RPG genre. Chuck in things like Bulletstorm, GOW3 and Deus Ex...next year could be an even better year for gamers than this year. Oh, and dont forget Michael Phelps for Kinect. |
|

Forum Posts: 2084 | Comment #57 by mjc0961 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 09:10:53 PM | |
Haha, nice joke about FF13 blending the best of the east with the best of the west. FF13 has the best of nothing and the worst of everything. It shouldn't be anywhere near a "best of" list. Did Square Enix send you guys some nice gift baskets or something? "Need For Speed: Hot Pursuit proved that even the most unsalvageable franchises can be brought back from the brink, no matter how lost they really are" Sonic the Hedgehog would like to come on stage and object to this statement, but he's too busy falling into numerous bottomless pits, getting dash-pad launched into enemies, playing with gimmicky powerups, and being violently rapped in the bum via way of a physics engine downgrade to actually make it. Also I know this is about 360 games, but I still gagged a little when I saw EA get 2nd place for best publisher. Again, not a 360 game, but C&C4. 'Nuff said. Anyway personal disagreements aside, that was still a great read. Also, thank you for not pulling a GameSpot and just picking Red Dead Redemption for every possible category. Happy new year to you as well. :) |
|

Forum Posts: 877 | Comment #58 by Giptuc Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 09:14:01 PM | |
@33 Yes, but the multiplayer is the same as its been since CoD4, just with different guns and maps. OT: Gotta Agree with pretty much all of the results here, cept dissapointment of the year needed to go to all three of the results with a tie >.> |
|

Forum Posts: 114 | Comment #59 by Prime8 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 10:15:42 PM | |
| I was expecting Medal of Honor to get Biggest Disappointment (or at least runner up), but other than that, the list is pretty solid. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #60 by Tkbacon99 Friday, December 31, 2010 @ 10:55:08 PM | |
| @58 I know it is the same kind of, but I don't think that we should evaluate it on that.I just overall think BO should be a runner up instead of ACB. Basically if we were to evaluate every game on wheter its the same as the last game, then why did Reach win? Please don't interpret this as saying I hate Reach, but really all that's different from Reach (without weapons,guns etc.) Is 2 new modes online and just a little more customization. |
|

Forum Posts: 4 | Comment #61 by sKiNnBoNeS 101 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 12:17:04 AM | |
| Wat. RDR is totally goty but other than good list |
|

Forum Posts: 33 | Comment #62 by HeadLikeAHole Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 01:29:14 AM | |
| good choices exept from best mp (assassin creed), goty (alan wake) and developper (ubi montreal) |
|

Forum Posts: 17 | Comment #63 by Paravan85 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 01:34:38 AM | |
Yay for Platinum games and Bayonetta! :D Im honestly suprised Platinum actually won best dev. and the fact Bayonetta was a runner up for GOTY, as the only praise i really see it get is from the staff and a barely anyone else. Well im happy with the awards, especially Bayonetta winning 1 and running up for GOTY :D |
|

Forum Posts: 302 | Comment #64 by x LeXXuz x Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 01:46:42 AM | |
| I couldn't agree more. ME2 won GOTY and Alan Wake best story. Good choice! |
|

Forum Posts: 16 | Comment #65 by callmeclean Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 04:15:48 AM | |
| The only problem I have is with best devleoper, sure platnium may have made two great games quickly showing they are good at making games but being a great devleoper is supporting your game with things out of the box, because people play great games and they don't really care about the developer unless the developer give them reasons to. I think Bungie should have won because not only have they the best news service around telling people what is happening about the Halo community right back to mods for the original Halo, a weekly news service telling you so many things about the development of the games, stats system online and now in game, forums and a truly awesome community as well as file search online. I think to be a good developer you have to inform people about you and give them more then just great games to please them even further which bungie truly does. Thats why I think they deserve it. Anyway good list always love to read the opions of the staff on the site. |
|

Forum Posts: 243 | Comment #66 by Toathy Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 04:16:32 AM | |
Bayonetta does not belong in the GOTY categorie! It should have gone. 1.Halo Reach 2.Mass Effect 2 3.Alan Wake but thats my opinion and that doesnt realy matter now does it? Anyway list was fun to read through. I do dissagree on a few of your choices. I STONGLY DISSAGREE WITH GOTY! |
|

Forum Posts: 16 | Comment #67 by callmeclean Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 04:20:59 AM | |
| The only problem I have is with best devleoper, sure platnium may have made two great games quickly showing they are good at making games but being a great devleoper is supporting your game with things out of the box, because people play great games and they don't really care about the developer unless the developer give them reasons to. I think Bungie should have won because not only have they the best news service around telling people what is happening about the Halo community right back to mods for the original Halo, a weekly news service telling you so many things about the development of the games, stats system online and now in game, forums and a truly awesome community as well as file search online. I think to be a good developer you have to inform people about you and give them more then just great games to please them even further which bungie truly does. Thats why I think they deserve it. Anyway good list always love to read the opions of the staff on the site. |
|

Forum Posts: 329 | Comment #68 by Heroic Blanket Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 05:49:58 AM | |
| It feels so good to not see COD anywhere in this list. |
|

Forum Posts: 8 | Comment #69 by Steviewonder023 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 06:21:14 AM | |
| Well out of my predictions I got 4 correct in which most comes from my GOTY: Mass Effect 2 |
|

Forum Posts: 221 | Comment #70 by SK L4xX Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 06:21:41 AM | |
| wait...bayonetta came out in 2009...why is it on the 2010 list? |
|

Forum Posts: 877 | Comment #71 by Giptuc Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 06:35:22 AM | |
@60 That is true about Reach, but it still brought a lot of new features to the whole halo mutliplayer that black ops just didnt seem to improve on. Honestly, if the Black Ops multiplayer was more like World at War, it would have been great, but it seemed like with Black Ops, Treyarch just took TOO much from MW and MW2 that they shouldnt have to make the multiplayer really innovative |
|

Forum Posts: 30 | Comment #72 by Man On The Run Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 07:53:40 AM | |
| Those that dispute Bayonetta when did you start playing games? Its a great throwback to the old days of awesome gameplay and fun with unlockables galore, varied level design and great boss fights. |
|

Forum Posts: 384 | Comment #73 by B0seiju Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 07:57:49 AM | |
@ 41 I totally agree with you, I don't have any connection with RDR. It's just a game that I can't get into. I've played it over at a friends house for 3 hours straight and I just didn't get that whole I'm in this story feeling. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #74 by Webb [STAFF] Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 08:01:27 AM | |
| @#70 - In Japan, yes, but not in North America and Europe. January 5th and January 8th release date respectively. |
|

Forum Posts: 38 | Comment #75 by Aussie27Legend Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 08:32:04 AM | |
Sad that Red Dead didn't make the short list of GOTY candidates, but I do agree with most of the picks. Castlevania was fucking amazing, sad nearly every review (for some reason) bagged it. |
|

Forum Posts: 38 | Comment #76 by Aussie27Legend Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 08:37:19 AM | |
| Also, where the hell was Super Meat Boy :( |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #77 by BigJoeBallz Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 09:21:29 AM | |
| @70 Bayonettea released Jan 2010 |
|

Forum Posts: 4 | Comment #78 by Fata1Stryke Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 10:01:20 AM | |
@16 As much as I love Mass Effect, and as beautiful as it was, I have to agree that Castlevania was definitely up there. Aesthetically it was one of the most well-realized fantasy worlds I've seen. It did seem like it had a few more rough edges though. Good list X360A, I haven't been able to play enough of these games but I at least agree with what I do know. |
|

Forum Posts: 1 | Comment #79 by BenIsJammin138 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 11:03:29 AM | |
| I totally agree with Mass Effect 2 being game of the year. I actually fell in love with that game. Glad to see Black Ops wasn't even mentioned. It was average at best. Good list guys. |
|

Forum Posts: 12 | Comment #80 by Statiic Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 12:10:47 PM | |
| Greg Hastings' Paintball 2 was pretty disappointing, it felt like they downgraded from the first one. |
|

Forum Posts: 4 | Comment #81 by DragonFox27 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 12:39:11 PM | |
| I'm so happy to see that RDR isn't even mentioned in GOTY! It's a piece of crap while Mass Effect 2 is a masterpiece! |
|

Forum Posts: 95 | Comment #82 by Nick Is I Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 12:42:52 PM | |
| Everyone needs to hop off of Halo and Call of Duty's cock. The games aren't even that good. They have been making the same game year after year with slight adjustments. When they finally do something different, then they should be considered for winning awards again. |
|

Forum Posts: 10 | Comment #83 by Biohazard214 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 12:48:30 PM | |
| @5 sold mine after a couple days of playing. hated the new br and multiplayer. stick to my old SWAT in Halo 3 |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #84 by Webb [STAFF] Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 01:23:21 PM | |
| @#82 - Forge called, it wonders why you ignore it so much. |
|

Forum Posts: 190 | Comment #85 by ash356 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 02:09:11 PM | |
Reach = Best multiplayer? No way, creed was probably more deserving to be honest. Reach has only 9 maps, excluding DLC, which is pretty poor to be honest. Especially considering only sword base and variants of forge world are the only ones played, with powerhouse occasionally popping up. Spot on with dissapointment, best score, and nice to see Activision didn't get a look-in on best publisher :P Ones got to wonder whether the communities attitudes towards COD is affecting your decisions though - My love for Cod games wavered somewhat on MW2, but I have to admit Black ops is a good game. It's not like Reach (albeit a great game) is a huge leap from Halo 3 anyway :/ |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #86 by TANGO at your 6 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 02:34:29 PM | |
| pretty good list. im glad to see that COD did not get best online, or GOTY because lets face it, the campaigns in the CODs are the only thing that is worth playing. Now im off to get Mass Effect 2 which i was so mean to not pick up on previous trips to gamestop. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #87 by Webb [STAFF] Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 02:40:49 PM | |
| @#85 - We love COD as much as the next gamer (check our reviews for instance) =) |
|

Forum Posts: 1000 | Comment #88 by Dr Popodopolus Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 02:43:24 PM | |
"All those glitches" in Red Dead, funny how I never encountered a single one. But I'm not complaining as the game is amazing. Personally the Halo Reach MP bored me a lot more so than Halo 2 and 3. I found myself addicted to Halo 3 for a good year or two, Halo Reach lasted about a week or two. Not so great. Personally I would have had Red Dead Redemptions soundtrack right up there, but hey I'm being a Red Dead fanboy purely because I CAN! |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #89 by Tkbacon99 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 02:58:33 PM | |
| @71 Again Reach MP was good, but what new features besides the 2 I listed are there? I just can't think of any others. |
|

Forum Posts: 17 | Comment #90 by Mr Chr15topher Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 03:30:45 PM | |
| Halo Reach for original score? Have you guys never listened to ME2's "Suicide Mission"!? |
|

Forum Posts: 41 | Comment #91 by Gravehammer Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 04:32:20 PM | |
| Mass Effect 2 for GOTY? Really? It was good. but it wasn't nearly THAT good. |
|

Forum Posts: 96 | Comment #92 by TSG Dwaggie Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 05:45:57 PM | |
| I think I called about 80% of these. Yay :D |
|

Forum Posts: 82 | Comment #93 by FaTaL EFX Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 06:16:27 PM | |
Meh, obviously it's subjective, but I don't see it myself. Mass Effect 2, GOTY... A game with a horrendously thought out main plot, that lacks logic, steps side-ways rather than forward, and isn't as well written as people claim. [It's very odd that you pretty much criticize the plot when giving it runner up for "best story", as though what are ultimately side-missions should be looked at in the same light as say Nier, or AC : Brotherhoods plot. A game with a combat system that rips out all the RPG elements and skill, making it a poor Gears of War imitation like 90% of third person shooters on the market. A game with a poor musical score [how it won runner up in that category I'll never know, especially with the likes of Nier, Bayonetta and Resonance of Fate all having stellar scores...]. A game that removes a large degree of the moral choices from the franchise, the one big choice you do get to make is so ridiculous and laughably written it'd be foolish to really call it a choice...[I'm not seeing the articles claim of "depth"]. A game with a save system similar to previous Bioware games, and one that didn't even work properly [see the whole "who did you choice to be human ambassador decision" from the first game that they didn't transfer]. A game that removed any sense of scope the previous games held, making the game-world consist of nothing but small, often entirely linear areas. In all I highly disagree, and think ME2 is far to over-praised by those that refuse to look beyond the shine and pretty graphics...there's nothing particularly revolutionary about slapping a conversation wheel on a TPS [which is all Mass Effect 2 is at the end of the day] and we shouldn't be praising developers that, half-way through a trilogy, create highly polished filler content. Mass Effect 2 has no reason to exist in its current form, the DLC is something else [outstanding], but the main game ultimately moves the franchise side-ways, not forwards, to the final game, and that shouldn't be praised. Other than that I felt these choices were fairly well thought out. Platinum deserved to be developer of the year, simply because they made two amazing games that deserve even more praise than they receive from most sites. RDR won a few things, and I'm pleased to see Alan Wakes interesting story rewarded. @67 "but being a great devleoper is supporting your game with things out of the box, because people play great games and they don't really care about the developer unless the developer give them reasons to" So you're saying that "Best developer" shouldn't go to a small developer that creates two unique IP's that succeed in the west simply because they are so much fun to play, despite their massively contradicting styles, but to a large company that gives players more information? I'm at a loss to comprehend such a comment... |
|

Forum Posts: 3 | Comment #94 by FYS Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 07:02:46 PM | |
F1 grahics were better than mass effects graphics and rdr should have been game of the year |
|

Forum Posts: 1313 | Comment #95 by Jellybean468 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 07:15:18 PM | |
| I would have chose half of the list differently, but eh, guess we all have our own opinions. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #96 by Webb [STAFF] Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 07:28:05 PM | |
| @#93 - If stating a plot is not as good as the original means the plot is bad, then colour us guilty. It doesn't though =P I could sit here all day and pick holes in your logic, from the "poor" score down to the decision making save system (you pick out one decision and ignore the hundreds of others? That seems picky.), but it wouldn't do either of us any good, because opinions are like assholes... everyone has one. And usually, it's an opinion that they stand by and won't be swayed. You obviously don't like Mass Effect 2, that much is abundantly clear, but there are, I'd say, millions of others that totally disagree with your criticisms on almost every front. Me being one =P |
|

Forum Posts: 2 | Comment #97 by Freakinaction Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 08:12:56 PM | |
| For me, the Best Multiplayers of the Year is Battlefield: Bad Compagny 2 and the Biggest Disappointment of the Year is Medal of Honor. |
|

Forum Posts: 82 | Comment #98 by FaTaL EFX Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 08:25:42 PM | |
@96 "If stating a plot is not as good as the original means the plot is bad, then colour us guilty. It doesn't though =P" I didn't state you said it was bad. It is, but you didn't say it. You did however criticize it, if you felt the need to do so whilst awarding the game a "best story" award, does that not take away from its "I could sit here all day and pick holes in your logic, from the "poor" score down to the decision making save system (you pick out one decision and ignore the hundreds of others? " First and foremost you couldn't pick holes in my logic regarding the "poor score' because music is entirely subjective [as in I didn't fully state my reasoning behind my point], what isn't subjective is the way the game utilizes its score and how it impacts on the game. Mass Effect 2's score didn't really ever do that, compared to say, Bayonetta. The game didn't use the music for dramatic effect, or to put more emphasis on the scale of a fight [hence Bayonetta], hence, it's a "poor score". It's just there filler, generic music. Sure the theme song is nice, but for the most part the score is empty bells and whistles [figuratively] that does nothing to bring the world to life. The point regarding the save system wasn't so much that it was bad, there was nothing wrong with it [bar the big decision you make at the end of the first game not being recognized, that's still a pretty big flaw however you try to defend it] but rather that it wasn't innovative, despite your claims [and awards] that it was...it was done, by Bioware no less, before, and not really expanded on massively beyond the way you'd expect a giant company with the man power to do so would have done. It's not the sort of thing that shouldn't be rewarded. "millions of others that totally disagree with your criticisms on almost every front." I'm sure there're also millions who also think Call of Duty games are the best ever made...people like shiny things. Mass Effect 2 is an easy game to play, and is very shiny... Pretentious? Sure. But when you're pretty much arguing over opinions you have to be... "You obviously don't like Mass Effect 2" I don't like what Mass Effect 2 did to the Mass Effect franchise, as a core game on its own it's not an abysmal game, but it does massive damage to the potential of the franchise... |
|

Forum Posts: 1 | Comment #99 by BenIsJammin138 Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 08:49:11 PM | |
| @96 Webb, well said. |
|

Forum Posts: 82 | Comment #100 by FaTaL EFX Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 09:39:45 PM | |
Ugh @98 forgot to finish my first paragraph: "I didn't state you said it was bad. It is, but you didn't say it. You did however criticize it, if you felt the need to do so whilst awarding the game a "best story" award, does that not take away from its..." ...overall prestige as a storyline. If it's not as good as Bioware 101 [which Mass Effect was; Bioware have pretty much used the same basic plot elements for all their RPG games - as much as I like Mass Effect and Dragon Age] then why is it deserving of such praise? On a side-note, I'm finished with this debate - you clearly enjoy Mass Effect, and you're happy with the changes, I disagree with your point of view and although I can see why you might think the way you do I still feel you're ignoring certain faults in the game, regardless it's your call if you beleive they're acceptable within the game, not mine. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #101 by Webb [STAFF] Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 09:41:18 PM | |
@#98 - The save thing... "It was done by BioWare before"? Not to this extent. Nowhere near it actually and to insinuate otherwise is just plain misleading. Yadda yadda... Yeah, like I said, opinions. Assholes. Can't change someone's mind. I honestly just think you're being overly analytical for the sake of it though, because you didn't like BioWare's approach to the sequel. I bet you made your mind up before you played it. Anyway, their streamlining of its RPG and improvement of its TPS side obviously wasn't to your taste, but as an RPG aficionado who's played both the original and the sequel more times than I care to remember, the franchise is doing pretty damn well I reckon. |
|

Forum Posts: 82 | Comment #102 by FaTaL EFX Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 10:06:00 PM | |
@101 I said I wasn't going to reply, but then I saw this, really? "I bet you made your mind up before you played it." That's not only entirely inaccurate [I was incredibly hyped for ME2 and got it on launch day], but it's also you attempting to make excuses as to why I feel as I do about the game, for the game. It's not my fault I didn't like the game, it's the games fault it didn't meet expectations, and "streamlined" [that's what they called it anyway] the game so it barely resembles the first game. As for being "overly analytical", in what manner? The breakdown of the story? Being such an "RPG aficionado" yourself you must know how important story is to the genre, and how in an RPG a badly designed story, with a number of small holes, can bring the whole thing down with it. But there isn't even a small hole in Mass Effect 2, it's gigantic, right from the beginning anyone who hasn't played the first game, completed heaps of the [poorly done and boring] side-missions in the first game, read the first games Codex [and who really read that thing?] and read the books is going to be alienated simply by the focus on The Collectors and the Illusive Man. That is if they like clear explanations and expect big things from the likes of Bioware, as I do. "The save thing... "It was done by BioWare before"? Not to this extent. Nowhere near it actually and to insinuate otherwise is just plain misleading." So what if it's not to this extent? Is MAG on the PS3 incredibly innovative because it has over 100 players per side on a console? Sure it's bigger, but it's not anymore innovative than the next death-match shooter, from a gameplay perspective. |
|

Forum Posts: 32 | Comment #103 by cstbrophy Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 10:13:54 PM | |
my top 3 games: 1. mass effect 2 2. red dead redemption 3. just cause 2 |
|

Forum Posts: 147 | Comment #104 by W1cked Seraph Saturday, January 01, 2011 @ 10:50:50 PM | |
| Another list another laugh |
|

Forum Posts: 150 | Comment #105 by JackJumpsCandle Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 12:07:44 AM | |
| Mass Effect 2 is a great winner with TONS of replay value to find everything. Haven't checked out Bayonetta yet though... |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #106 by MielikkisChosen Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 02:13:52 AM | |
| It's about time a site gave Halo: Reach some praise. It deserves it. |
|

Forum Posts: 493 | Comment #107 by EcT Felix Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 04:09:38 AM | |
i used the Mass Effect 2 manual to take the shit away from my ass.. BUt we have our own opinions. and i actually enjoyed Force Unleashed 2! :) |
|

Forum Posts: 190 | Comment #108 by ash356 Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 07:14:13 AM | |
@87 True, I suppose. Reach is a damn good game, so I'll give you it to be fair. Truth be told, I couldn't have called that one. You should consider having a 'buggiest' release category. *Cough* New Vegas *Cough* |
|

Forum Posts: 447 | Comment #109 by fax5jrj Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 09:22:40 AM | |
| I agree with most of these, but I think that Bungie is the best developer, and I still don't get how The Force Unleashed II is a disappointment. It was a hell of a lot better than the first game. |
|

Forum Posts: 55 | Comment #110 by dasheq Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 09:38:35 AM | |
Reach has got a good enough multiplayer but definately not the best. The whole matchmaking system is one word 'crap'. Can't join after the game has started, no balancing of teams, too many forge maps you should have really considered that. However, I'm happy not to see black ops in this list. :] |
|

Forum Posts: 458 | Comment #111 by x DIAM0NDZ Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 09:52:40 AM | |
I love Castlevania! If Bayonneta is one of the Game of the year winner, I might give it a try! |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #112 by Webb [STAFF] Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 12:01:41 PM | |
@#102 - To me, it sounds like you're bitter because BioWare made some changes that you didn't like. If you liked Dragon Age, don't play the sequel then... you might just cry. It's called evolving a franchise. And evolve it they have. You're clutching at straws as well to be honest... MAG... really? Next you'll say that creating a vehicle that travels the speed of light won't be innovative because it's just faster than a car. Like I said, no-one is going to change their opinion based on anything that anyone says, so I'm not sure why I'm bothering, but just know, that your opinion is that of the minority, which might say something about what you're missing. FYI - the Collectors and the TIM are given more than adequate background in the ME2 game itself... Just because they don't spell it out for you, doesn't mean it's a plot hole. Ask Darth Vadar. |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #113 by ashe647 Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 12:01:44 PM | |
| Much love for giving Mass Effect 2 Goty, i thoroughly enjoyed it from start to finish! Same goes for Limbo, something a little different that was really enjoyable! Good choices all round! |
|

Forum Posts: 918 | Comment #114 by Dcon6393 Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 12:02:48 PM | |
Damn, right after I get a bunch of great games I read this and want to pick up Bayonetta and Mass Effect 2. This list is great, loved all of the different awards as opposed to best action game, or best family game. |
|

Forum Posts: 32 | Comment #115 by blackbriar83 Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 03:30:45 PM | |
| @93 all ya had to say was, Mass Effect 2 GOTY??? I disagree. But then ya go of on one and after 3 lines, all I hear is Blah Blah Blah... GOTY Mass Effect 2 its there choice!!! |
|

Forum Posts: 36 | Comment #116 by JT Gregory Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 06:18:36 PM | |
| Too many essays in the comments!!! me2 was immense but acb is my goty and i aint even finished it yet! |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #117 by andrewwsmith Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 08:40:14 PM | |
| no black ops at all? |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #118 by Ironhand Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 09:39:51 PM | |
| Webb, I like the list but where is awards for best achievement and best achievement tile? I enjoyed seeing those I mean this is and achievement website.... |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #119 by Webb [STAFF] Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 10:09:40 PM | |
| @#118 - They come on our birthday in Feb. We like to keep the two separate =) |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #120 by Tkbacon99 Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 10:15:10 PM | |
| @117 Thought the same thing man |
|

Forum Posts: 89 | Comment #121 by strawberry Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 11:23:45 PM | |
| why was super meat boy not at least nominated? |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #122 by BS LIKE A BOSS Sunday, January 02, 2011 @ 11:46:59 PM | |
I am very happy to see no Call of Duty. Sure I think Black Ops was way better than Modern Warfare 2 but the whole serious is overatted. Halo Reach for best multiplayer give me a break. By far the Multiplayer of the year was Battlefield Bad Company 2. @117 Black Ops really really, lol screw Call of Duty |
|

Forum Posts: 26 | Comment #123 by SuddenJonatan Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 12:32:27 AM | |
| Glad to see Alan Wake here. My GOTY |
|

Forum Posts: 1012 | Comment #124 by Magicman10893 Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 12:57:47 AM | |
In response to the people complaining about the human council member choice, that was a mistake made with Mass Effect 1. The save that is made at the end of the game to be used for New Game Pluses was made at the beginning of the cutscene where Shepard crawls out of the wreckage. The part where you talk with the Council and nominate either Anderson or Udina is after that save and another save isn't made to over wright it. That is why you have to choose at the beginning segment of Mass Effect 2 who you nominated to be the human council member. So complaining about that "glitch" isn't going to back your point up, although the glitch with Conrad Vernor is a legitimate glitch, however it doesn't really change things with his story. I still contend that the save file transfer system in Mass Effect 2 should win. Even though it was done in the past, it is still an excellent feature that definitely added a lot of depth to the game. I actually went back and played through Mass Effect 1 twice and began a third play through just for the purpose of transferring it into Mass Effect 2 to see how those choices played out in the long run. I imagine with the release of Mass Effect 3 I will be going back AGAIN and running through BOTH Mass Effect 1 and 3 multiple times to specifically tailor my personally desired plot. Not many RPGs can get me that involving, that is why I whole heartedly agree with Mass Effect 2 being game of the year and am already making my prediction for Mass Effect 3 being 2011's GOTY. If ME3 isn't the GOTY then it will be because it got delayed into 2012. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #125 by Tkbacon99 Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 01:11:19 AM | |
| @122 I dont know how you can say Black Ops didn't deserve anything... its MP was better than ACB. My main reasoning behind it is the fact that Black Ops has a more replay rating as ACB did, plus BO's story was pretty good, so don't say it didn't deserve anything cause it did. I think everybodys reasoning behind hating the game so much is because Call of Duty is in front of it, and is a behemoth franchise. Plus with everyone having MW2 sickness it is really sad seing such a good game getting no recognition. |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #126 by II BOMBSCARE II Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 02:46:47 AM | |
| all i can say is the goty award is truely deserved ME2 for the win, by far the best gaming experience i had last year and i've played most the big releases last year, think i'm gonna have to get bayonetta and castlevania |
|

Forum Posts: 176 | Comment #127 by maur1c1o Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 05:05:04 AM | |
| Im sorry but what a crappy review first there was no good RPG out this year second fable sucks its so overated third Halo sucks its also so overated mass effect is far better than halo i personaly dont play either as i cant stand anything to with space althou i have finished halo 3 on multiplier format i thought it was a good shooting game but overall it was dispointing apart from the constant killing of every alien as for mass affect i really enjoy it but i cant play it for too long as im cant stand space shit again but i thought it was a beautiful game just not my thing Fable II is one of the worst RPG ive played people really need to stop following others i mean Assasin creed is not even that good for goodness sake its one of the most repetive games ive played i had more fun playing kung panda and listening to jack black for goodness sake i find a lot of these titles are blown out of proportion almost like the media are telling people waht to play and everyine seems to go with it personaly games like bad company kane and lynch are underrated although kane and lynch 2 was disappointing i just think the media over hype games i personally cant believe brag so much about some titles and i decided to try them only to find they arent very good and wished i had never bothered another is fallout cant stand it way overated rather play borderlands Red dead was the outstanding game of the year as well as enslaved personaly rockstar know how to make a game even though i hated the gameplay of GTA IV it was a nicely told story with great characters just couldent stand the controls. |
|

Forum Posts: 29 | Comment #128 by whisperinthewind Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 07:39:24 AM | |
@127 Dont you know how to use a full stop, man? Jeeze |
|

Forum Posts: 1951 | Comment #129 by martdude16 Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 09:20:41 AM | |
I thought Bayonetta was a good game but not amazing. I can understand people rating it highly though. Mass Effect 2 was my GOTY also! Good list. |
|

Forum Posts: 86 | Comment #130 by NerfTurbo Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 09:42:47 AM | |
| It was nice to see Bayonetta and Castlevania win something |
|

Forum Posts: 82 | Comment #131 by FaTaL EFX Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 09:56:04 AM | |
@112 "To me, it sounds like you're bitter because BioWare made some changes that you didn't like. If you liked Dragon Age, don't play the sequel then... you might just cry. It's called evolving a franchise. And evolve it they have." If by "evolve" you mean dumb-down in pretty much every conceivable sense bar graphics, then yes, they most certainly did. To me it sounds like you're willing to defend Mass Effect 2 [despite the massive amount of flaws already presented to you], whilst ignoring said flaws, because you're not thinking analytically. "You're clutching at straws as well to be honest... MAG... really? Next you'll say that creating a vehicle that travels the speed of light won't be innovative because it's just faster than a car." Um..what? That's one of the worst analogies I've ever seen, mainly because it has nothing to do with the point. We're talking about gameplay innovation, in video-games. Comparing the slight advancement of an already existing system, in a video-game, to a vehicle that travels at the speed of light? And you claim I'm clutching at straws... [so says the person who argued I was being "over analytical..." -_- ] "Like I said, no-one is going to change their opinion based on anything that anyone says, so I'm not sure why I'm bothering" Well if you made a decent argument I might, you've just pretty much ignored any points you can't argue against, and have done a terrible job defending other elements [such as the story being within the books, hell you've even changed your ideas as to where this information is stored below your argue ME2 contains more than enough references for former players, which is a really poor argument in of itself.] "but just know, that your opinion is that of the minority, which might say something about what you're missing." Like I said, the majority of gamers are uninformed, don't know what they want and just generally praise anything shiny. It's the lowest common denominator, and that's the type of person Mass Effect 2 appeals to. Just because it's popular doesn't mean it's a good game - see Modern Warfare 2 and Final Fantasy XIII. "FYI - the Collectors and the TIM are given more than adequate background in the ME2 game itself...Just because they don't spell it out for you, doesn't mean it's a plot hole. Ask Darth Vadar." Ok, I get the point, you're delusional. I apologize for expecting some kind of logical debate, I should have known better with the number of logical fallacies and general excuses made by yourself throughout this debate. If it's not explained, it's a plot hole, if they expect you, as a chaarcter you're meant to be role-playing, to supposedly understand who this person is, yet the player themselves does not, that's just horrendous writing. You keep claiming, over and over "no-one is going to change their opinion based on anything that anyone says, so I'm not sure why I'm bothering" yet still you respond. I can only assume that's because you see, despite your self-professed fanboy-like love for the series, some form of logic. If it's anything else you're just wasting your time. Regardless, unless you make another statement so blatantly false I feel the need to respond just to set you straight, I'm finished with this debate. As stated previously, I beleive you to be delusional, some of your arguments have been very poor, and you've often ignored any counter-points, or indeed, any points it appears you can't argue against. This includes your small attempts to discredit my opinion as being "bitter" or "clutching at straws" because I'd prefer to see the games industry evolves beyond said lowest common denominator. |
|

Forum Posts: 82 | Comment #132 by FaTaL EFX Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 10:01:02 AM | |
@124 "So complaining about that "glitch" isn't going to back your point up," You remember when Bioware announced Mass Effect to be a trilogy? You'd think they'd have implemented this system as strongly as possible, seeing as how it's a key selling point for them. Arguing that poor implementation of a feature doesn't back up that point is moronic at best, I don't think it was ever named a "glitch" [as you supposedly quoted], but whatever the case it's still a big issue with the system, and more proof, if any was needed, that Bioware really didn't think about Mass Effect 2 properly. |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #133 by roza Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 11:09:08 AM | |
| ah shit! i coulda got Mass Effect 2 for a fiver! If i knew it was THAT good idve got it! |
|

Forum Posts: 1000 | Comment #134 by Dr Popodopolus Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 08:06:19 PM | |
| @133 £5, I don't get it, if Mass Effect 2 is so brilliant then why has its street value plummeted to as low as £5 in less than a year. Even CoD 4 stayed at £30 for a good 2 years or so until MW2. |
|

Forum Posts: 82 | Comment #135 by FaTaL EFX Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 08:58:34 PM | |
@134 Because CoD4 is a massive exception, not the rule...don't say "Even" as though it's a regular occurrence. The video-game market usually goes as such, a game is released and it'll sell about 90-95% [made up figures but you know what I mean] of the total amount of sales for that game in its first two weeks of release. From there retailers will gradually lower the price, as the original flow of income [those hyped about the game, impulse buyers coming off reviews and so on] stems, they attempt to sell a few more copies by lowering the price. Though I don't think @133 was referring to the street price, I've never seen a game retailer sell a new game for £5 so they might have bought it off a friend or something - who knows, they don't specify. Regardless, CoD4 was insanely popular, and therefore it was efficient for retailers to keep its price as high as possible. People would buy it to play with their friends on the online multi-player, something Mass Effect doesn't have [and I pray they don't add], thus the game continued to sell strongly months and months after launch. As for why it's still so pricey? I'm not sure, I guess retailers are quite happy keeping the price as it is - the game is still reasonably popular, simply due to the franchise name. Again, not something Mass Effect has with your average consumer [you don't see non-gamers talk about Mass Effect for example, whilst Call of Duty is the new "Google it" in terms of a brand name referring to an action. In short, quality doesn't equal market value in this industry [not that I beleive ME2 is quality anyway] game prices drop very quickly, it's something games companies are trying to solve, as games only have one shot to sell well - see Alan Wakes market flop due to it releasing the same time as other AAA games - but CoD4 is the only game so popular it has stayed at a high price for years. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #136 by Webb [STAFF] Monday, January 03, 2011 @ 10:13:11 PM | |
@#Fatal - Okay, you're going a little overboard now. I started to read your response, but then realised I'd read enough crap from you and had given up caring. I read up to the Collectors bit where you called me delusional and was overcome with a sense of irony. It's like talking to a brick wall with you. Go get some sunshine. New rule, if you want to chat with people in the comments, send them a postcard... or PM/email/Tweet/appropriate social networking message. It's time to get the comments back on track. Oh, and stop thumbing up your own comments. You forget I can see who does what remember ;) *ushers the comments back on track* |
|

Forum Posts: 4 | Comment #138 by LeviXLush Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 12:20:36 AM | |
| Must be Black Ops didn't come out in 2010? I don't even play Call of Duty, really let alone Xbox anymore...but why is everyone on the teat of Bungie? Halo was revolutionary when the first came out. Halo 2 pumped it all up. Halo 3 was netgen woohoo, then people starting shifting to Call of Duty 4 because hello, it was great. ODST...that wasn't even a game, was it? Now Reach...Halo 3 with different guns and a few other things. I mean come on....it's not good. It gets popularity from pre-teen kids and virgins, and honestly go into games and listen to the people talk, it's true. Get over Halo all ready, it's nothing special anymore, Call of Duty pulls in WAY more people and that's a fact. Sorry, Bungie. |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #139 by roza Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 05:12:48 AM | |
@135 no Mass Effect 2 brand new and wrapped for £5 at Game in the Sale. @138 The reason CoD attracts people because its more 'Modern' and has real weapons and people think 'ooh this is what war is like'. Halo is more fantasy with all these aliens and plasma weaopns, most people can't take it seriously. Halo is much better a series because it is original and actually has a solid story line. CoD is just 'kill the enemy' and every level your doing some new crap. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #141 by Tkbacon99 Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 09:27:19 AM | |
@139 I have to disagree with your view of what CoD is like... I think the reason why CoD people can't play Halo now (this is my view since I can barely play it anymore) is because it is such a kiddish game. You're shooting aliens with plasma and guns and all there is that makes it mature rating is a splash of blood. If I was hit by a plasma bullet, wouldn't you expect my body to either be burnt to shit or there to be a hole? They need to put some realism into Halo if they want CoD player to come back. And come on... CoD stories actually have a story behind... give it a little more recognition than that. |
|

Forum Posts: 199 | Comment #142 by ViNyLek Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 10:18:09 AM | |
| I like the list, though not agree wholly. Let's just leave it at that. At two above me: COD has way better gameplay, grahpics and story, but when it comes to content and soundtrack, you can't beat halo series:-P In other words something for everyone^^ |
|

Forum Posts: 62 | Comment #143 by Thiago123 Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 10:18:16 AM | |
| I was with you guys until the arcade game category. Limbo is the winner for me too, but how is Raskulls or Costume Quest even in the conversation and not Super Meat Boy?? |
|

Forum Posts: 600 | Comment #144 by xCHICKEN DIXx Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 11:14:46 AM | |
| wow what a shit list some can be agreed with others are clearly wrong but 2 each his own |
|

Forum Posts: 147 | Comment #145 by Medaking Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 11:45:12 AM | |
| Bayonetta and Vanquish are complete and utter overrated, hunks of shit. |
|

Forum Posts: 77 | Comment #146 by Caxton Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 02:14:36 PM | |
| yey castlevania got an award :D Freaking loved that game. Alot better than gamespot picking red dead to receive everything |
|

Forum Posts: 330 | Comment #147 by ch9209live Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 05:46:45 PM | |
| i'm fine with everything else, but GOTY (based on demo), but would i vote Halo: Reach as GOTY? no, my GOTY is AC: Brotherhood, next years GOTY: Batman: Arkham City |
|

Forum Posts: 2522 | Comment #148 by jamie1000013 Tuesday, January 04, 2011 @ 10:51:22 PM | |
Most disappointing should have been Kane and Lynch 2 instead of Crackdown 2. I don't think Mass Effect 2's graphics were that good, Alan Wake's graphics were pretty amazing. Mafia 2's graphics were also pretty top notch. Singularity did shock me, it was 10X better than I thought it would be. I also loved sniper:Ghost Warrior, I would like to see a follow up to that. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #149 by Gone Rampant Wednesday, January 05, 2011 @ 05:18:35 AM | |
| Crackdown 2 and Force Unleashed were great in my opinion- Never liked HAWX in the first place, would have put Kane and Lynch 2 and Army of 2 40th Day instead. ME2 for GOTY? Yeah, bu thank merciful Christ Cock Of Doody didn't even get nominated! Halo deserved best multiplayer, but Bayonetta for 3rd game? WTF? Other than that, was nodding in aggrement. Good show, X360! |
|

Forum Posts: 23 | Comment #150 by GeoKazDav Wednesday, January 05, 2011 @ 12:25:28 PM | |
| Im really glad that Dead Rising Two at least got a mention, possibly one of the bast games I've played on the 360. |
|

Forum Posts: 64 | Comment #151 by SoundableObject Wednesday, January 05, 2011 @ 04:35:09 PM | |
I loved Crackdown 2. Not as much playability as in the original and it was just a re-hash but frankly sometimes more of the same is exactly what you want, sometimes... Would have put Halo Reach as the GOTY with Mass Effect 2 in second. Mass Effect 2 certainly deserves the best graphics though, the design of the Normandy 2 interior is beautiful, it makes it a joy to walk through and chase up all those side missions. The opening with the destruction of the original Normandy was also very well done as was the mission were you need to recover the dog tags at the Normandy crash site. |
|

Forum Posts: 22 | Comment #152 by KickedSpoon Wednesday, January 05, 2011 @ 06:22:10 PM | |
| Ii own bayonetta and enjoyed it but I'm not totally on board with it in the runner up for game of the year. Still it was ok. Congrats to Alan wake on it's win. |
|

Forum Posts: 150 | Comment #153 by BrandAid1138 Thursday, January 06, 2011 @ 01:41:03 PM | |
| @ 136...man...i love reading this soap opera between you 2. Oh and remember with opinions and A-holes....we all have'em AND THEY STINK!!! Anyhoo....good list. Keep up the good work. |
|

Forum Posts: 37 | Comment #154 by The EliteStick Thursday, January 06, 2011 @ 04:10:45 PM | |
Webb, I completely love Mass Effect 1 and Mass Effect 2 but I can see where that guy is coming from with his negatives and think they are valid. Whilst I personally don't think they spoil the experience enough for me to not enjoy it, I do agree with what he is saying. You seem to be ripping into him for voicing his own opinion in a completely non abusive way. Sure as hell shows that you run your website in a way akin to Stalin - people can voice their opinion as long as it is yours. If you really want to argue with people for what their post then do it with me for what I am about to say: Webb, you are a cunt |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #156 by Bash Callihoo Friday, January 07, 2011 @ 02:22:40 AM | |
@154 You were making a decent point, then you went overboard and became an asshole. Plus, who seriously goes out of their way to do that? Anyhoo, I'm really glad Bayonetta was recognized by you guys, I finished it just a little while ago and it is a truly amazing game. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #157 by Webb [STAFF] Friday, January 07, 2011 @ 10:50:28 AM | |
@#154 - Valid points? He ignored everything I said. That's when you realise that everything you say or do is futile, and it's best off to say... we'll agree to disagree, but he was obviously looking for a fight. As are you. Oh and thanks... it means a lot. |
|

Forum Posts: 123 | Comment #158 by DonnyRoversFal Friday, January 07, 2011 @ 12:20:08 PM | |
Webb, i am not looking for a fight but i think if someone is going overboard it is you. You seem to go on the defensive every time someone disagrees with you and even insult some people, which i do find inappropriate considering you should be 'leading by example' so to say. You are very trigger happy when it come to 'banning people' who either disagree with you or insult you and i really think you need to get off of your high horse and come back down to earth and see that you are no better than anyone who visits this website. I'm sure you won't agree with this and you'll ban me because of course that how you hide away from people who disagree with you. However, should you wish to discuss this personal matter in a PM then just let me know. On topic however, Alan Wake should have won the new franchise of the year award but hey thats my opinion and i am entitled to it. |
|

Forum Posts: 388 | Comment #159 by TESTUBE BABY 82 Friday, January 07, 2011 @ 01:51:07 PM | |
| i think everybody should and will voice there opinion on this site,freedom of speech without consequences |
|

Forum Posts: 173 | Comment #160 by Epilogue of Euphoria Friday, January 07, 2011 @ 04:57:36 PM | |
I don't agree with half of your choices, but to each his/her own. And I don't care what anyone says, beyond the story of Lords of Shadow the game is awful. Finally people see Unleashed 2 for the crappy game it really is, thought I was the only one there for awhile. Why no love for Enslaved? It's one of the best games out there. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #161 by Webb [STAFF] Friday, January 07, 2011 @ 05:01:06 PM | |
@#158 - I'm sorry you feel that way, but that couldn't be any further from the truth. I'm not sure how long you've been round here Donny, but I'd like to think that anyone who knows me around here knows that's not the case. I'm up for a good debate everyday of the week and do so more often than not in the comments, but when it goes on for a while and goes nowhere, I have to do my duty and drop out and steer it back on track. Agree to disagree, as I said. If I ask the comments to get back on track after it goes way off topic like it did here, then I expect the person to respect my wishes, not totally ignore what I say, after all, I still have to maintain order round here and that is my primary duty. I could drop off and not comment at all, but I like to think that the fact the writers are on the same level as the readers round here is one of our charms. However, if people can't debate and listen to us when we ask them something, then we may as well just slope away into the shadows. However, I will not let the minority spoil it for the majority. @#159 - Freedom of speech on a privately owned website? You've been watching too many movies =P I've said my peace and I think I've been pretty thorough in my explanation. Now, can we please finally get back on topic =) If people want to debate this, then you know my email addy ;) Only GOTY speak from here on out please people. |
|

Forum Posts: 7 | Comment #162 by Metaljunkie93 Friday, January 07, 2011 @ 07:38:16 PM | |
| Am happy that Alan Wake, Red Dead, & Halo: Reach won something. Am also happy that Cock of Duty: Gay Ops didn't win anything! |
|

Forum Posts: 153 | Comment #163 by THe Silent Assassin Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 08:16:53 AM | |
Alan Wake SOTY - I dont agree with that RDR or ME2 should have won But the whole list was redeemed when Mass Effect 2 won GOTY |
|

Forum Posts: 594 | Comment #164 by x 19 Luke 87 x Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 01:39:32 PM | |
| Not suprised this site gave alot to Mass Effect. |
|

Forum Posts: 510 | Comment #165 by Battosai343 Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 05:39:49 PM | |
x360a's GOTY awards>IGN's. Well thought out; I agreed with most of the awards. :) |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #166 by Webb [STAFF] Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 05:42:22 PM | |
| @#164 - 2? =P |
|

Forum Posts: 1314 | Comment #167 by ThePumpkinKing Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 06:40:42 PM | |
@Webb - With nominations in 5 categories, not counting the nod to Bioware (primarily influenced I'm sure by ME2) in the developer category. Best DLC winner. Mentions on the top 5 of best worlds, characters, and trailers. Don't get me wrong, ME2 was great. A solid game. But game of the year it is not. Nor did it have any place whatsoever winning DLC of the year with the sub-par Shadow Broker DLC. Not to mention, the ME3 teaser is about as anti-climactic (for several reasons) as it gets. Why that craptastic trailer made the list over the superior ME2 launch trailer is beyond me. Again, ME is a great series. But the ridiculous, nearly comical level of praise "your site and staff" has given it is a bad joke to anyone sensible enough to have outgrown the "fanboy" stage of their life. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #168 by Darwon99 Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 07:39:53 PM | |
| i didnt play mass effect 2 might have to check it out |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #169 by Webb [STAFF] Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 08:37:12 PM | |
| @#167 - Like I said, each to their own. Just reading through the comments though, it shows we're not alone in our high praise =) Also, if you look at its Metacritic value of 96%, that puts it as the 4th highest rated Xbox 360 game ever, something we wholeheartedly agree with. It's a case of different strokes for different folks, that's all. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #170 by (:TLB:)Shok Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 08:53:50 PM | |
| I don't think I'll ever understand the love Halo Reach gets. I've only played it for a bit but the gameplay feels just so... bland. My game of the year would be Bayonetta or Mass Effect 2. The first Mass Effect just disgusted me, I think it had something to do with an endless conversation loop between two aliens that helped me in no manner. After a couple of hours I gave up. Mass Effect 2 however felt like it changed so much, and for the better. Now the reason I loved Bayonetta is because I love boo- I mean the gameplay was fun and it constantly barraged you with awards. |
|

Forum Posts: 176 | Comment #171 by Dredgon Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 09:02:31 PM | |
| ME 2 FTW!!!!! |
|

Forum Posts: 10 | Comment #172 by my_bitter_end Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 09:34:11 PM | |
| People seem to have a strong disapproval of Mass Effect 2 winning GOTY. This isn't the only site that gave it that award. At the same time it is just an opinion. Arguing about choices and what certain games got awarded is pointless really. People will argue that the likes of Black Ops or Fallout New Vegas should have been in there and maybe Kinect should have gotten a mention. At the end of the day it's different horses for different courses. I personally agree with some of these choices, I disagree with some. Saying a game is "Fucking shit" or that "you are disgusted with it" just because some game you prefered didn't get the praise you wanted it to doesn't mean you have to go off on one. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #173 by FOURTHxSURVIVOR Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 10:15:19 PM | |
| Thanks for throwing a bone to Singularity - it was a great piece of scifi that went totally overlooked, it was one of my favorite games of 2010. |
|

Forum Posts: 4610 | Comment #174 by hydrosugar Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 10:54:04 PM | |
well i'm happy that black ops didnt get undue recognition, and that bayonetta/platinum games did. also kudos on noticing f1 2010 for graphics instead of just pilling on the shooters, havent picked it up yet but am meaning to. wouldve been nice to see naruto uns2 get a graphics mention though, consiedering they did everything they aimed to do and more. |
|

Forum Posts: 4610 | Comment #175 by hydrosugar Saturday, January 08, 2011 @ 10:56:10 PM | |
| ^^^ also i poorly worded my comment. bayonetta/platinum didnt get undue recognition, but instead got the recognition they deserved |
|

Forum Posts: 130 | Comment #176 by Jimmy Hapa Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 03:46:04 AM | |
| So glad Platinum Games got the best dev award. They really are one of the best new large development teams around (IMO, THE best), which is largely unrecognized by your average gaming Joe, unfortunately. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #177 by Tkbacon99 Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 05:19:17 AM | |
| @174 Why didnt Black Ops deserve any recognition? It was a great game... lemme guess, the Call of Duty in front of it makes it non deserving? |
|

Forum Posts: 27 | Comment #178 by hartlesdalegend Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 07:16:28 AM | |
| GOTY: where is Red Dead Redemption, Fable 3. Didn't play Bayonetta so have no opinion but RDR was my GOTR by a slight margin over Fable 3 and Halo: Reach. |
|

Forum Posts: 27 | Comment #179 by Arawos Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 07:24:58 AM | |
| I think RDR was better than ME2 so that is the GOTY to me. The great question I now have? - GOTY 2011: ME3 or TES V: Skyrim?? |
|

Forum Posts: 40 | Comment #180 by Richters Shadow Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 10:17:13 AM | |
| @ 179, I bet Skyrim! If it is half as life destroying as Oblivion then it'll be GOTY! ME3 though will still likely kick ass - unless it's all on Earth... |
|

Forum Posts: 9531 | Comment #181 by Carmona25 Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 10:26:02 AM | |
| I haven't played any Mass Effect but I heard the second was was bad. I guess I'm wrong cause it one GOTY. I always believed it was, cause it's selling for $19.95. |
|

Forum Posts: 30 | Comment #182 by Scottish Sin Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 10:58:28 AM | |
Am I the only one that thought Fable III was one of the biggest disappointments of the year? I loved the first and second, but Fable III never clicked. I thought the story was a lot weaker and the part where you actually play the role as the king/queen felt very rushed and disjointed. It also didn't help that there were a lot of the same enemies & locations with not much varation at all. It just felt like more of the same but not as good as Fable II. I dunno, for me at least it lacked the same kind of magic that past Fable games had. Other than that, I agree with most of the list. Mass Effect 2 was also my personal GOTY and one of the best universies ever created. Really looking forward to the third. |
|

Forum Posts: 28 | Comment #183 by Bramwell420 Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 11:28:35 AM | |
Overall I would agree with most of these, but Halo: Reach for best multiplayer just erks me the wrong way. The game does have a very large and defensive fan base, but in my opinion Battlefield Bad Companny 2 has the best multiplayer experience. I am talking about gameplay and fun factor. I realise that the customization in Halo was prob. the deciding factor, as modes such as Forge are absent in BBC2, but I am a grown man so I have no need to collect different shoulder pads and helmets that serve no purpose at all in the field of battle. Agree with me or disagree, just know that I am not trying to diss on Halo so there is no need for fanboy hate. I own both games and Halo Reach is a great game, I just feel like the level sizes and destructable environments set Battlefield above the rest. I also prefer realistic games, so I admit I am a bit biased. My friend and I have this argument all the time, he says Halo is better because it is a true measure of a players skill because, "Someone can be shooting you in the back and if you're a better player you can turn around and kill them in Halo." He never gets it that reasons like that are why I prefer Battlefield, you shoot someone in the back, they die. As it should be. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #184 by Webb [STAFF] Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 11:36:40 AM | |
| @#183 - It wasn't so much the customisation for us - we actually talk about it a bit on last week's podcast - it was more to do the fact that with Halo, every game is a level playing field, but in BC2, a level 20, with all the class unlocks, will have an advantage over a level 1. That was the deciding factor for us. Like I said though, it was a coin flip effectively and it came down to that. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #185 by CheesyToast111 Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 05:11:15 PM | |
| I have agreed with the majority of these, mainly the Mass Effect 2 awards which are well deserved for such an amazing game. But I really don't think that RDR should have been in the best story; I loved the game, amazing graphics, fun gameplay etc. but I found the story painful. I think that something like ACB or Fable 3 could have been a runner-up definately agree with Alan Wake though, fantastic game. Was suprised to see Just Cause 2 in here, alright game; the grapple hook is really fun. |
|

Forum Posts: 31 | Comment #186 by RunDMC Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 05:12:23 PM | |
| Halo? No. |
|

Forum Posts: 4 | Comment #187 by PsycoSaurus Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 05:56:02 PM | |
| Arcade Game = South Park Let's Go Tower Defence Play... FTW! |
|

Forum Posts: 712 | Comment #188 by Bajan Elite Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 08:41:16 PM | |
| I disagree with ME2 being GOTY, the story wasn't as good as the first, there was no improvement to the A.I. mainly your allies. The planet probing was very boring. They didn't "evolve" the RPG elements of the game. They replaced the option to assign different types of armor to your squad members, as well as the different weapons and ammo types like in the first. Also they could have done a better job of earning your teammates' loyalties instead of having to do the errands aka loyalty missions. The gameplay was great but the cover system was also problematic at times. ME2 is an outstanding game no doubt but not GOTY IMO. |
|

Forum Posts: 173 | Comment #189 by Blue Thunder28 Sunday, January 09, 2011 @ 11:33:18 PM | |
| Perfect list. Love it. |
|

Forum Posts: 597 | Comment #190 by TheToiletBrush Monday, January 10, 2011 @ 11:08:42 AM | |
| I honestly don't understand all the Reach love. I like me some Halo, but that was the biggest disappointment of the year for me. I had high hopes for something epic, and all I got was a "B" level shooter with a pointless story. It did have a good soundtrack....I'll give it that. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #191 by Wardon Monday, January 10, 2011 @ 04:15:07 PM | |
| Great choices and Im REALLY happy that someone finally mention Castlevania: LoS, its an amazing game, cant believe some website gave it disappointment of the year. The only thing I would add to the list is Super Meat Boy for Arcade Game of the Year. |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #192 by andrewwsmith Monday, January 10, 2011 @ 05:06:18 PM | |
| if u all hate black ops so much y wasnt it in the biggest disappoint list + its graphics used real people (u cant get any better graphics than that) |
|

Forum Posts: 84 | Comment #193 by MonkeyPunchBaby Monday, January 10, 2011 @ 06:28:14 PM | |
| I am agreed with this list much more than any other list i have seen. I love Bayonetta, Limbo, Red Dead Redemption and Alan Wake. Granted I haven't played Mass Effect 1 or 2, but I don't see how its soooo much better than all the games i played this year and loved. |
|

Forum Posts: 26 | Comment #194 by BigDaddyDirtHog Monday, January 10, 2011 @ 08:40:06 PM | |
| Limbo doesn't deserve arcade game of the year. It has no story, soundtrack, character development, etc, etc. Oh my god it's black and white! So was TV in the 50s...Over-rated |
|

Forum Posts: 111 | Comment #195 by NeoSant Monday, January 10, 2011 @ 09:17:06 PM | |
| Where the f*** its black ops... best selling game means something... disagree on this list in almost everything |
|

Forum Posts: 138 | Comment #196 by Japanese Table Monday, January 10, 2011 @ 11:44:13 PM | |
| Mass Effect 2 really shouldn't be GOTY. I could see it win a Audio Book with some decent Gameplay book of the year, but RDR was actually fun, unlike Mass Effect 1 and 2, and soon to be 3. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #197 by N7 x ORIGIN Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 01:39:26 AM | |
| Reaches multiplayer was lackluster (in my opinion). Theres a few thumbs down, but if you think about it, it shipped with only 9 maps and a visual upgrade from H3. Still a great game just not the best multiplayer (in my opinion). After these awards I might just have to go play Bayonetta but I think I would have to agree with everything on this list. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #198 by Webb [STAFF] Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 04:02:29 AM | |
| @#195 - Does it? Sales mean absolutely nothing. The next COD could be the worst title ever, but would still sell more than all the new IPs of 2011 put together. |
|

Forum Posts: 25 | Comment #199 by FatalFlaw810 Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 06:38:11 AM | |
| People need to understand this is all opinion, if they don't agree with the list they can make their own :/ It was a very good list I'm surprised Vanquish wasn't in the running along with Bayonetta. Platinum games is great =) |
|

Forum Posts: 128 | Comment #200 by Zombiechild Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 07:08:45 AM | |
Vanquish should of been on there as GOTY! truely fun game apart from that agree with most of the above, ME2 did feel abit to lite in the RPG and ropie in stroy sense and was more FPS than TPS but was enjoyable not going to restart the roflment as found above, as webb says each there own! Im a Hardcore RPG player if it dont have a story that could fill 3 books, character building that requires a spread sheet and a maths degree its a dumb down floaty lite RPG :P |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #201 by Epic5ofSpades Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 08:04:10 AM | |
| Really glad to see that Fable did make an imprint, I really enjoyed it. And also glad to see that you haven't dropped to your knees to worship black ops. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #202 by AlexisInFlames Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 09:22:13 AM | |
| Mass Effect 2 shouldnt have got goty, it should have gotten 2nd. Mass Effect is my favorite game series however i believe red dead did something new whereas me2 didnt |
|

Forum Posts: 5900 | Comment #203 by Opiate42 Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 09:42:17 AM | |
No I just skimmed the witicisms and sarcastic comments, but still worthwhile. All Hail Mass Effect 2!!!! ME3 can't get released soon enough for my liking. The wait will be worth it. |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #204 by McNerget Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 11:51:47 AM | |
| @5 Not at all! Reach is so over hyped. |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #205 by timm the zombie Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 01:34:42 PM | |
Mass Effect 2 was one of the best games I've ever played. The absolutely beautiful openning sequence stands as one of the best ever. RDR also deserves everything they got. It's such a deep experience that never dulls. I loved GTA4 but I bored of it. RDR has such a great story, and you can waste hours just hunting, playing poker, and doing the little side missions. Castlevania sounds great I'm gonna have to give it a try. I saw it at E3 but didn't get a chance to play and I keep forgetting about it. |
|

Forum Posts: 467 | Comment #206 by NawtyCawty Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 03:24:27 PM | |
| Wow Mass Effect 2 must be good. I have never played it personally as the first one was so fucking dull and annoying I didnt bother. But cant argue with too many of the choices, apart from Rock Band of course. I cant see how it can even be classed as a game to be honest, let alone have innovative feature of the year. Oh well. Far too many sequels in 2010 for my liking, lets hope 2011 has some original games, though I very much doubt it. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #207 by sonicdevron Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 09:10:54 PM | |
| I actually agree with most of the list besides the Rock Band part, but, I'm biased for not liking music games much. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #208 by Liek50Ninjas Tuesday, January 11, 2011 @ 11:53:15 PM | |
@18 Did you seriously just call Reach "underrated"? Really? That really happened and I'm not hallucinating? the fuck man? |
|

Forum Posts: 62 | Comment #209 by Allan Caesar Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 04:08:47 AM | |
My only complaint is that Super Meat Boy was not a choice to be nominated. :( Other then that, i am very happy Mass Effect 2 won Game of the Year. it deserved it. Unlike Gamespot giving everything to Red Dead. Jesus.. |
|

Forum Posts: 401 | Comment #210 by ademlakey Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 05:24:33 AM | |
| better than gamespots choices. |
|

Forum Posts: 2 | Comment #211 by Rigger X Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 05:37:57 AM | |
I was pretty surprised with Mass Effect 2 getting GOTY, not going to complain about it, just surprised. Only game I do not agree with on the list is Halo Reach for best multiplayer... meh. |
|

Forum Posts: 3543 | Comment #212 by niko da bos Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 10:41:00 AM | |
| reach best multiplayer... what a joke |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #213 by Tkbacon99 Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 01:21:57 PM | |
| @201 Really? Drop your knees? It is a good game, and the only reason why you probably hate it because it has Call of Duty in the front of it. Please everyone, go to the doctor and get cured of the MW2 disease, and you will see that Black Ops isn't that bad of a game. |
|

Forum Posts: 411 | Comment #214 by buck wyyld Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 02:22:28 PM | |
| Reach totally rules--everything else trails. Mass Effect 2 is a nice choice for GOTY, though--definitely one of the only interesting RPG's out there. Nice choices, based on what I've played. Good job, guys. |
|

Forum Posts: 1518 | Comment #215 by MASS DOMINATION Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 03:46:43 PM | |
this is one of the best lists I've seen from all the gaming sites i visit. there are some awards i disagree with (best new IP, biggest surprise), but u can never get what u want with every award. my favourite games were mass effect 2, alan wake, NFS, assassins creed and splinter cell. I'm glad ME2 got the biggest award but i would have given NFS, splinter cell or transformers a nomination for best multiplayer. I had the most fun all year when playing splinter cell deniable ops with a buddy and the inclusion of a second coop ONLY campaign is something deserving of an award imo. NFS was also great fun online and transformers completely blew me away with their online. i expected nothing from that game but i tried the demo, loved it, bought it, and played through the campaign and ranked up each unique robo-class to the max level without ever feeling like i was just grinding it for the achieveo's I would have swapped NFS for transformers in the "Biggest Surprise" category since i was very confident that NFS would be awesome since they went back to their roots and got criterion to make it. Transformers like i said, i thought was gonna be bad and turned out to be a great game. Overall though, a great list! |
|

Forum Posts: 937 | Comment #216 by Mr Deftino Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 05:51:06 PM | |
| Scott Pilgrim should have at least been a runner up in original score. The music in that game is incredible! |
|

Forum Posts: 1371 | Comment #217 by EMP Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 06:23:38 PM | |
| @5 don't hate it but it has become boring.. |
|

Forum Posts: 68 | Comment #218 by Kaifory Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 10:03:25 PM | |
| How did Halo beat FFXIII in Best Original Score? |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #219 by matt08buzz Wednesday, January 12, 2011 @ 10:14:34 PM | |
| post 3 |
|

Forum Posts: 8 | Comment #220 by Furl Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 05:30:05 AM | |
Hold on, let me get this straight. HALO IS A BETTER MULTIPLAYER GAME THAN BATTLEFILED. Sorry I just had to type that so I could actually see it. And now I've said it out loud a few times I think I realised something else. WTF WERE YOU THINKING!? HALO HAS A TERRIBLE MULTIPLAYER COMPARED TO BATTLEFIELD. Jesus I honestly have never seen anything so wrong in my entire life. |
|

Forum Posts: 57 | Comment #221 by queeg Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 06:30:35 AM | |
I disagree with most of this list, most strongly with limbo winning arcade game of the year. Super meat boy wins it hands down for me. Assassins creed brotherhood should of definately got best multiplayer as its actually new, whereas reach really isn't any different to halo 3. I've not played mass effect 2 but assassins creed definately has a better story than alan wake. If you disagree simple ask yourself who are they talking about during the end credits (hint, it's not desmond) |
|

Forum Posts: 2 | Comment #222 by reebokbl Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 06:36:00 AM | |
I would slightly change this list GOTY - Brotherhood, although it is published very late PUBLISHER - Ubisoft or Rockstar, not Microsoft people :))) many things I would like to change, even though there is a lot subjective SF-based opinion (too much Halo, Mass Effect bla bla bla...) I live in a country (Bosnia and Herzegovina) where there aren't so many Xbox consoles and people are nto so addicted to these kind of games, but poeple like Assassin's Creed, RDR, Just Cause etc. |
|

Forum Posts: 210 | Comment #223 by InFlames Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 12:52:36 PM | |
| I thought (or better hoped) that it actually could be Alan Wake! Anyway, a good choice! |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #224 by kenny d Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 02:31:07 PM | |
K As much as I enjoy playing Black Ops, Brotherhood, Reach, and RDR MORE than Mass Effect 2, you have to give the damn credit where credit is RIGHTFULLY DUE... MASS EFFECT 2 is not only a 360 game (hence why it should be a strong candidate for a site like this), but it's one of the only games ever that CARRY ON YOUR CHARACTERS' PROGRESS FROM THE FIRST! Amazing graphics, almost-as-good-as-Gears of War gameplay, great script, huge, epic scope, and it's lengthy enough for just 1 playthrough even! Black Ops, as much as it is the best COD game yet, it is not worthy enough, for its high reputation. Brotherhood, though the MP is unique and the SP is still great, it's not groundbreaking enough of a sequel, like AC2 was, which rightfully got it last year. Reach is the deepest, most polished shooter I've ever played, and the best overall 360 Halo game....it's a close runner-up RDR is such a marvellously-crafted game, and as immersive as a game gets this year, but it's still a bit too similar to GTA IV, so it's not that groundbreaking either. Fallout: New Vegas is everything I liked about Fallout 3 with more features, some that I was pissed off that wasn't in #3 (like not being able to ADS? FUCKING LAME!), but the glitches just doesn't make it deserving enough (as much as I love the game). Fable III I agree is NOT game of the year AT ALL, but IMO the MOST UNDERRATED GAME, and even the most underrated series...It has one of the best scripts, aesthetics, worlds, humour, and even some features that it brought to the table (with both games). Bayonetta, SC: Conviction and Alan Wake I'm sure are good games (but I'd personally want to play AW more :P), but they're too short, most likely. But yeah ME2 rightfully takes it :P |
|

Forum Posts: 39 | Comment #225 by Rodeo Legend Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 04:17:29 PM | |
| The only difference I would have made to this list would have been Mass Effect 2 winning all categories and the runners up too! |
|

Forum Posts: 26 | Comment #226 by Flekshin Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 04:27:09 PM | |
| halo reach doesn't deserve that much recognition. bungie focuses on putting out map packs before fixing things, and the maps are complete shit that came with the game anyways. |
|

Forum Posts: 3360 | Comment #227 by Yunder Thursday, January 13, 2011 @ 08:40:49 PM | |
| I liked Mass Effect 2... |
|

Forum Posts: 1 | Comment #228 by Shrimper77 Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 06:04:33 AM | |
| just pleased to see Black Ops, most over hyped rubbish, won exactly what it deserves ...nothing. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #229 by mrkilur Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 06:47:07 AM | |
@226 putting out map packs... that came with the game? need i say more? |
|

Forum Posts: 13 | Comment #230 by Dead Centurion Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 09:33:55 AM | |
| Im glad singularity got some recognition, its great when games like that deserve a mention and just because theyre not splattered all over your TV in advertising people miss them, Alan wake and ME2 are great games, black ops should have been in the category for multiplayer but i believe BF2 should have won, bayonetta is artistic and stylish but GOTY 3rd...really? i think people have just felt sorry for this game that didnt do to well and stuck it in there, and fallout new vegas, not even a mention, some good choices, but some bad ones guys |
|

Forum Posts: 16 | Comment #231 by Brother Cloud Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 10:26:45 AM | |
| I didn't think deadly premonition would make the cut, i loved alan wake, but deadly premonition had a better story. Glad black ops didn't win anything, so disapointed i went and bought cod4 again, what a game. Mass Effect 2 deserves goty, i'm glad you didn't make rdr win, was good but nothing special. |
|

Forum Posts: 512 | Comment #232 by lizard9979 Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 11:15:15 AM | |
Perfect awards ceremony if you ask me. Totally agree and love that you don't make your decisions based on the $$$$ a game made. You rock fellas. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #233 by Tkbacon99 Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 03:18:56 PM | |
| @228 How is Black Ops "rubbish"? People are calling it the best Call of Duty, even better than 4. Please explain how Black Ops sucks. Because I think you hate it because it has Call of Duty in front of it and you are still suffering from MW2 sickness. |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #234 by macou Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 03:41:10 PM | |
nass efect2 no 1 good game and good winner, but halo?? damn this game sucks even harder as halo 3 and odst. cant even think about buying this game, bungie still sucks, glad this was the last 1. early preview game of the year 2011 1.Gears of war3 2.bulletstorm 3.la noir 2011 will have the sickest relaeses ever |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #235 by XGamer Friday, January 14, 2011 @ 11:11:44 PM | |
| These game of year awards are wrong! Try again in 2011! |
|

Forum Posts: 486 | Comment #236 by A J Saturday, January 15, 2011 @ 05:18:49 AM | |
Wow ME is boring as hell, why game of the year? And why is Crackdown 2 classed as a dissappointment, it was awesome. AC: Brotherhood sould have got GOTY not boring Mass Effect. Let your fanboy thumbs down go crazy. . . |
|

Forum Posts: 28 | Comment #237 by uglytruth Saturday, January 15, 2011 @ 09:09:09 AM | |
| Why is fallout New Vegas never mentioned. I never saw it once on the xbox dashboard when it was released? Best rpg shooter in my opinion and to end the game droping the general off the hoover dam... priceless |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #238 by Devdawg17 Saturday, January 15, 2011 @ 09:27:48 AM | |
| In my humble opinion this is one of the best GOTY lists on any website i regularly visit. Nearly all ive seen have CodBlops as best shooter and RDR as Goty.both well made games, just not deserving of those awards. nice to see an original list with well written reasons behind those picks. Only disagreements are best shooter(id went with BC2)and the statement that ACB took a "sideways step" in the musical score department. Awesome list though, glad to see Castlevania grab up an award, a truly underrated game by most imo. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #239 by FoxViper1 Saturday, January 15, 2011 @ 11:17:43 AM | |
there should be more RDR awards(RDR had best multiplayer this year)IMO. |
|

Forum Posts: 38 | Comment #240 by Bl4nkShot Sunday, January 16, 2011 @ 02:20:29 AM | |
| see this is why i like this site. i completely agree with everything. they even mentioned alan wake and singularity, which i though were two under-appreciated games of the year! |
|

Forum Posts: 48 | Comment #241 by givemesomelager Sunday, January 16, 2011 @ 10:02:00 AM | |
| haha fanboy votes now im losing just as much respect for this site as i did gamefaqs |
|

Forum Posts: 1 | Comment #242 by KennyP702 Sunday, January 16, 2011 @ 11:50:01 AM | |
| Glad to see Bayonetta on there |
|

Forum Posts: 42 | Comment #243 by Quake007 Sunday, January 16, 2011 @ 11:57:16 AM | |
| @233, Who saya Cod BO is the best Cod out there? I want what they're smoking. |
|

Forum Posts: 45 | Comment #244 by pinkfluff1 Sunday, January 16, 2011 @ 06:11:32 PM | |
Battlefield deserves more kudos as it was just a total blast and never got old for me. Really made team work essential when other shooters lack that element to gaming that makes it so social. Mass Effect 2 was awesome as well and deserves its recognition Such a great year really :) |
|

Forum Posts: 6 | Comment #245 by Tkbacon99 Monday, January 17, 2011 @ 12:25:12 AM | |
| @243 Alot of people that I have played with have said this... I personally think CoD4 was the best but Black Ops has to be number 2 on my list. |
|

Forum Posts: 659 | Comment #246 by Blueprotoss Monday, January 17, 2011 @ 05:30:48 PM | |
The awards this year seems to be biased to the Exclusives even though Multiplatform titles deserved them. Best Story doesn't belong to Alan Wake because its jut another Stephen King novel. Best Multiplayer doesn't belong to Reach because there were more games that had better like Monday Night Combat, RDR, and Black Ops. Best Original Score belongs to Red Dead Redemption because it clearly had the better Score. The Best Publisher either belongs to EA for ME2/Hot Pursuit or Rockstar for the whole RDR package. Like I said this year belongs to the Multiplatform games because MS couldn't dish out a good Exclusive compared to great Multiform titles for 2010. |
|

Forum Posts: 43 | Comment #247 by Murphy Nox Tuesday, January 18, 2011 @ 09:01:15 AM | |
The people who say that Mass Effect 2 is a dumbed down version of Mass Effect 1 always make me laugh. They made the game much more streamlined and took out all the technical issues that were in Mass Effect 1, they got rid of that terrible inventory system and the broken Weapon Mod mechanic that made the game ridiculously easy, plus the bloody texture loading while in a conversation, eughh.... You guys that think it isn't an RPG because it removed these things don't even know what a RPG is in the first place. Mass Effect 2 was a much more refined game If you don't think that the Mod system was broken then you should attempt ME1 on Insanity. 2 was a lot more challenging cause the game was way more balanced. The only one I disagree with is Arcade Game of the Year, should've gone to Super Meat Boy. |
|

Forum Posts: 659 | Comment #248 by Blueprotoss Tuesday, January 18, 2011 @ 11:58:57 PM | |
| @ 247. Mass Effect 2 is a very dumbed down RPG just like Fable 2 because the target audience was the casual crowd for simple streamlined gameplay. You could say that ME2 was Gears with a very basic RPG system. |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #249 by TalesOfPants Wednesday, January 19, 2011 @ 01:09:37 PM | |
| I personally have to go with Bayonetta as my GOTY, but that'll obviously vary from person to person. It's easily the most fun I've had with a game in years. |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #250 by andrewwsmith Wednesday, January 19, 2011 @ 02:47:24 PM | |
| i like cheese |
|

Forum Posts: 49 | Comment #251 by simon_super_sheep Thursday, January 20, 2011 @ 08:02:40 AM | |
i dont play call of duty black op's but im suprised to not see it up there well done to halo reach it deserved multi player of the year i always thought halo reach multi player is better than halo 3 multi player. i would have liked to see assassins creed brotherhood in a few more list's but obviously looking at the list's it is hard competiton. good list hope next goty award's are as good as this goty award |
|

Forum Posts: 71 | Comment #252 by RTRD_Mayhem Thursday, January 20, 2011 @ 01:23:43 PM | |
| holy fucking comments. |
|

Forum Posts: 52 | Comment #253 by XGearskillerX Thursday, January 20, 2011 @ 11:21:02 PM | |
| Bayonetta was terrible! |
|

Forum Posts: 968 | Comment #254 by Ethereal235 Friday, January 21, 2011 @ 12:43:01 AM | |
I was surprised that RDR didn't get a nod for the soundtrack that game had. I thought the music really helped make the atmosphere for that game. I listen to it fairly often on my iPod. I'll have to check out of a few of these, when I have time. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #255 by jgates0923 Friday, January 21, 2011 @ 07:03:18 PM | |
| I have never understood why people argue that the runners up in the list like this deserve to be number one. Every list is subject to opinion and anyone with half a brain knows that ALL (yes, I said all), the games listed here are worthy of your time and money. The fact that they made the list at all out of hundreds of games this year proves your point and the opposing one. Where these games are placed doesn't matter, it's getting here that counts. |
|

Forum Posts: 356 | Comment #256 by KashThePriest Friday, January 21, 2011 @ 07:03:50 PM | |
| I found Bayonetta to not really be that original, it felt more like a Devil May Cry game imo so I was surprised to see it get so many noms but thought hey it won't win anything but it got best new franchise and top 3 for a lot of stuff which was pretty surprising to me |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #257 by darkwolf660 Friday, January 21, 2011 @ 07:31:07 PM | |
| my god there are so many comments |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #258 by Aidz999 Saturday, January 22, 2011 @ 07:18:16 AM | |
| 2010 was a great year for games, looking forward to the year ahead. Cant wait for GOW3! |
|

Forum Posts: 87 | Comment #259 by Zombii Panda Saturday, January 22, 2011 @ 04:48:13 PM | |
Bayonetta seems to be highly rated by you guys, I bought it ages ago but haven't even put it into my Xbox yet, like a lot of my games...I think I should give it a go in a bit. :) Other than that, I own most of the games on the top list so that's good. Hehe. (I also own most of the disappointing games too. e_e) |
|

Forum Posts: 5 | Comment #260 by The_Omnigamer Sunday, January 23, 2011 @ 04:00:10 AM | |
| So so so sooooo glad that Alan Wake won best story. Hands down, there shouldn't have been much of a contest in that department. Understand why it didn't win GotY, but at least out of all that I played, there wasn't a tale that twisted my mind more than that one. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #261 by IIXX Sunday, January 23, 2011 @ 04:23:09 PM | |
| good list but best multiplayer shouldn't have went to halo reach.. as much as i hate to say this, it honestly should've to Black Ops.. and that's not because im a cod fanboy (i already sold my black ops), its because of how many players are online. if you go look at halo reach, theres only like 1-200k people online, whereas black ops has min 600k a day. |
|

Forum Posts: 22 | Comment #262 by Jericho666 Sunday, January 23, 2011 @ 06:43:13 PM | |
| Don't agree with awarding a developer award to any company who implements the unfair to families 'online pass' system or any pre-order bonus that is one profile only and not registered to the console. So in short, EA,THQ or Ubisoft. |
|

Forum Posts: 77 | Comment #263 by St Jolly777 Monday, January 24, 2011 @ 01:00:58 PM | |
| Surprised Fallout NV didn't make disappointment of the year...it certainly was mine. |
|

Forum Posts: 172 | Comment #264 by chicaqo Tuesday, January 25, 2011 @ 04:55:32 PM | |
| Very good list |
|

Forum Posts: 42 | Comment #265 by Quake007 Tuesday, January 25, 2011 @ 08:32:42 PM | |
| @261 That's not what the award is based on. Popularity means nothing. |
|

Forum Posts: 12 | Comment #266 by Wintallica Saturday, January 29, 2011 @ 03:25:30 PM | |
| Black Ops has best multiplayer hands down. |
|

Forum Posts: 201 | Comment #267 by High Lord Sigma Saturday, January 29, 2011 @ 10:16:18 PM | |
| By the ad populum logic some people are using here, Sniper: Ghost Warrior should have been one of the best games of the year. Think about that. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #268 by fodom101 Monday, January 31, 2011 @ 02:13:10 AM | |
| The only one I do not agree with is the "Biggest Disappointment of The Year". The Force Unleashed 2 was a good game, not a great game, but a good one. There were more disappointing games out there in 2010. Also, Crackdown 2 was a great addition to the Crackdown franchise. It was fun, enjoyable, and very addictive. Medal of Honor to me, was the biggest disappointment of 2010. But, I can agree with Hawkx 2 being on the biggest disappointment list. |
|

Forum Posts: 62 | Comment #269 by Rolled Monday, January 31, 2011 @ 03:49:08 PM | |
| Wow didnt no mass effect 2 won GOTY, so random, where was Call of Duty on any of these awards??? |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #270 by James0741 Tuesday, February 01, 2011 @ 12:56:12 PM | |
| I got Mass Effect 2 and thought it was a great Sci-Fi game with excellent graphics, I played the 1st game twice because it was great but I played the 2nd one about 6 times over, I can't wait for Mass Effect 3! |
|

Forum Posts: 65 | Comment #271 by horrormoose Tuesday, February 01, 2011 @ 01:19:58 PM | |
Nice guys! I like the setup a lot, great awards and great winners. |
|

Forum Posts: 1 | Comment #272 by clusterbomber Tuesday, February 01, 2011 @ 04:19:41 PM | |
| game of the year for me was probably bad company 2 |
|

Forum Posts: 38 | Comment #273 by Play N Skillz Tuesday, February 01, 2011 @ 10:03:42 PM | |
| Call of duty may have a big community but that doesnt make it any better than the past few that i liked (WaW & 4) big respect for the x360a staff on giving the facts and not opinions about the games. Anyways I agree that the top 3 of last year should be Bayonetta, Halo, and Mass Effect all great games |
|

Forum Posts: 38 | Comment #274 by Play N Skillz Tuesday, February 01, 2011 @ 10:06:48 PM | |
| also i think Final Fantasy should take the score :) |
|

Forum Posts: 659 | Comment #275 by Blueprotoss Wednesday, February 02, 2011 @ 12:15:59 PM | |
@ 260. Alan Wake was just another Steven King novel, which made the game have an Unoriginal story. @ 273. They still gave out their own Opinions especially with the whole Exclusivity choices being the main thing on their list. If they gave out the Facts as going with the majority then the only competition would be RDR, Black Ops, Dead Rising 2, and Mass Effect. Also if they gave out the Facts then there would only be Multiplatform games on the list because the Exclusive titles in 2010 weren't up to pare with the Multiplatform titles. Bayonetta hd no reason for being on this list especially when Vanquish was the better Devil May Cry game of 2010. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #276 by Epic V2 Tuesday, April 12, 2011 @ 02:52:22 PM | |
| Mass effect 2 is game of the year for me! |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #277 by shockfire3DG Saturday, May 07, 2011 @ 03:51:32 PM | |
| Reach is awesome. I'm glad it won something. |
|

Forum Posts: 105 | Comment #278 by StyledBear Friday, May 13, 2011 @ 06:26:47 PM | |
| Mass Effect 2, fantastic game which whilst not up to its predecessor still eclipsed anything else this year. IMO of course... |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #279 by Tomafork XD FTW Tuesday, December 27, 2011 @ 01:22:30 AM | |
| @55 fallout & rdr ftw! |
|