
Forum Posts: 831 | Comment #1 by Feel My Rage Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 10:51:51 PM | |
| Haha, i think #'s 1 and 2 are well deserved! Another great list guys! keep it up! |
|

Forum Posts: 268 | Comment #2 by Lord of Orion Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 10:52:57 PM | |
| I am glad Modern Warfare 2 won this. They put a lot of work in the cut scenes and deserve it, even if the story got a little carried away. |
|

Forum Posts: 12 | Comment #3 by HT101 Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 10:55:11 PM | |
| Great list again. Didn't check the GTA 4 one since I haven't played BoGT yet so I don't want to spoil it for myself. |
|

Forum Posts: 182 | Comment #4 by Dave of Canada Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 10:57:21 PM | |
I agree with all picks except for Resident Evil 5. Personally, it felt out of place for a horror game and felt more like an action game. Then again, the game is an action game pretty much. :P |
|

Forum Posts: 430 | Comment #5 by PakoRawr Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 11:24:17 PM | |
Pretty Solid List. Modern Warfare Tend to eliminate Player characters in shocking ways, it's sad :(. |
|

Forum Posts: 2084 | Comment #6 by mjc0961 Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 11:27:08 PM | |
| Wait, Rocksteady actually had the game tell the console to display the RROD instead of the normal controller light when that part happened? |
|

Forum Posts: 119 | Comment #7 by linkin10362 Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 11:37:26 PM | |
| @6 no,the screen looks as if you are getting a red ring by freezing up and doing some weird noises.My friend turned the game off 3 times because of that part before finding out it was a trick,fun stuff. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #8 by Webb [STAFF] Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 11:48:25 PM | |
| @#7 - Admittedly, so did I, ha ha. Only twice though =P I was scared it jumped back to the beginning and the autosave would lose all my progress, so I turned off twice and then Googled it. Damn those buggers! |
|

Forum Posts: 118 | Comment #9 by FiNaL Mirage Tuesday, December 22, 2009 @ 11:48:29 PM | |
| Awesome list, all deserve to be up there. |
|

Forum Posts: 183 | Comment #10 by SoBeRxFTW Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 12:08:26 AM | |
| Modern Warfare 2 cutscene really deserved it, because it was kind of emotional. FUCKIN SHEPARD!! ='[ |
|

Forum Posts: 3350 | Comment #11 by Yunder Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 12:13:53 AM | |
| Look at Harley Quinn shaking her hips in that cutscene. ;)Damn. |
|

Forum Posts: 2084 | Comment #12 by mjc0961 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 12:28:19 AM | |
Oh, alright. Thanks #7. The PS3 version did the same thing, but when I read the article I thought they actually made the 360 show the red ring. Would have been a nice bonus for the "DAMMIT MY GAME FROZE!" moment they had there. My favorite part of that is "use the middle stick to dodge Joker's gunfire", though. At first I thought I really died, and then I saw the "middle" part. Good one Rocksteady. :p |
|

Forum Posts: 119 | Comment #13 by linkin10362 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 12:53:48 AM | |
| @#12 Yeah your welcome,I liked that part as well,I forgot what exactly it told me to press,but I know if you tried to skip the cutscene,it told you to press the "J" button,thought that was pretty funny as well |
|

Forum Posts: 126 | Comment #14 by FirsthandJordy1 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 01:42:23 AM | |
What about The Cole Trains AWESOME cutscene ?!?! Number 5 I remember and number one |
|

Forum Posts: 112 | Comment #15 by XxHamRxX Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 01:58:39 AM | |
| I dont care at all about story in any thing cos i cant follow it but i still got taken aback by #1. It is that emotional |
|

Forum Posts: 131 | Comment #16 by The Dark Wyvern Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 02:52:10 AM | |
| Ahh Scarecrow was the greatest villain in Arkham Asylum. That part was a serious mind-fuck. |
|

Forum Posts: 324 | Comment #17 by MrIacob Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 02:58:23 AM | |
| Best list could be made. |
|

Forum Posts: 47 | Comment #18 by eggflip66 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 03:27:39 AM | |
| mw2 won because so many retards bought the game |
|

Forum Posts: 193 | Comment #19 by sneh Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 03:49:05 AM | |
| totally agree with the #1 pick. the feeling of total betrayal made me want to kick a small dog. |
|

Forum Posts: 58 | Comment #20 by S Luker 92 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 03:50:17 AM | |
| I loved the Batman one made me crap myself seeing as I'm on my third Xbox! MW2 deserved winner. |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #21 by reg12365 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 04:04:06 AM | |
@14 That wasn't 2009 @18 Shut up....-.- |
|

Forum Posts: 40 | Comment #22 by crazyman Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 04:29:09 AM | |
the modern warfare series is amazing, but always seems to make me want to gauge my eyes out, feed them to a small KILLER WHALE and stay alive so i can watch myself get eaten, from the inside of that KILLER WHALE, and be slowly digested untill i don't exist. they are the best games ever, but seriously; -griggs getting headshotted, -captain price 'dying' at the end of mw1 -ghost and roach being betrayed and burnt CRAP!!! STOP KILLING EVERYONE AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!! but on a lighter note, a good top 5 :) |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #23 by CheesyToast111 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 05:16:47 AM | |
@22 YOU FORGOT GAZ! The Halo Wars cutscenes were fucking good |
|

Forum Posts: 881 | Comment #24 by BlindxLink Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 05:17:59 AM | |
| I got so scared on the Batman scene when I first played. I'll never forget it. |
|

Forum Posts: 1501 | Comment #25 by Midnight Malice Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 05:46:05 AM | |
| Hmmm, the betrayal was good for storyline, but did it really make for a good enough cutscene for #1? A good cutscene is something you can watch independantly from the story and go... awesome... these were top 5 scenes, not top 5 plot twists. Halo Wars is the perfect example of cutscene gold, you watch it alone and it is sweet, show that MW2 scene to someone that has never played the game, they would go... uh ok. You would have to explain why it is good, destroying the whole idea of a good cutscene. Noobs.... |
|

Forum Posts: 1501 | Comment #26 by Midnight Malice Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 05:48:30 AM | |
| After reading the opening, it sounds like they chose thier 5 first, then gave justification as to why they were there. Whatever... |
|

Forum Posts: 223 | Comment #27 by Shadow Warlock Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 05:54:04 AM | |
| Batman should have got #1 and Overhyped Warfare 2 #3. |
|

Forum Posts: 14708 | Comment #28 by Webb [STAFF] Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 06:54:47 AM | |
| @#25 - Actually, cutscenes are designed to advance plot. They aren't created to just look good. So it's only natural we give the winner to the scene that advances plot and creates an emotional response in an unforgettable way, a la Modern Warfare 2. |
|

Forum Posts: 179 | Comment #29 by xgonscm2 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 06:55:09 AM | |
| are you serious about the batman one....that's the only reason i stopped playing that game, i even deleted my save info and started again, got to that point in the game, and it happened again. i feel like a total dumb shit right about now...lmao |
|

Forum Posts: 1951 | Comment #30 by martdude16 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 07:06:03 AM | |
Great list, Modern Warfare cutscene was brilliant as was RE5! However just incase some people haven't seen the cutscenes yet, you could add a spoiler. |
|

Forum Posts: 13639 | Comment #31 by B A R 4 D Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 07:06:31 AM | |
| I loved the Halo one bt MW2 was also pretty sick..damn sheppard. |
|

Forum Posts: 25 | Comment #32 by jirvine64 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 07:10:28 AM | |
The guy at IW who decided to kill off Ghost is an asshole I hope he has a bad Christmas tbh R.I.P Ghost :( |
|

Forum Posts: 1951 | Comment #33 by martdude16 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 07:11:36 AM | |
| ...Nevermind, it says on the opening page. My bad! :) |
|

Forum Posts: 119 | Comment #34 by Desmondo2000 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 07:17:54 AM | |
| Damn you Shepard! |
|

Forum Posts: 96 | Comment #35 by Aliasalpha Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 08:16:28 AM | |
I almost shat myself with the Arkham Asylum one. It was the day I got the game and the day I got the PS3 I was playing the game on so I was extra worried by that, Clever bastards, to this day I don't know if I want to hug them or kill them |
|

Forum Posts: 96 | Comment #36 by Aliasalpha Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 08:17:58 AM | |
| Oh yeah, and "Use middle stick to aboid gunfire" when the joker shoots you... bastards, I actually looked for it! |
|

Forum Posts: 1818 | Comment #37 by InkedUp Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 08:27:47 AM | |
Good list Webb, MW2 definitely deserved the #1 spot. @18 I must have missed the part where people who bought the games could vote on the Top 5 for the year, since you seem to be saying that all the "retards" who bought MW2 had a say so in these Top 5 cutscenes, or maybe your referring to Webb as a retard, which isn't to smart of you. Put a little thought into your post before you type. |
|

Forum Posts: 212 | Comment #38 by Jimbob131190 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 08:31:43 AM | |
| I only played MW2, but from the videos i've to say I think Batman should be replaced with Halo wars. Also that makes me want to play my resident evil now XD |
|

Forum Posts: 30 | Comment #39 by Astrex Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 08:57:23 AM | |
| I got to admit the M Dub ya 2 one had my heart racing! |
|

Forum Posts: 1135 | Comment #40 by H0p3sfalL Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 09:25:27 AM | |
| NICE LIST !!!!!! liked the halo wars one a lot..... got to love the human spirit! But i felt when price launched the nuke should have been # 1. I mean at that point in the game that was where i had my jaw the lowest with a hint of a grin for the awesomenes of it all. |
|

Forum Posts: 40 | Comment #41 by Grimm Tim Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 10:04:03 AM | |
| Awesome list. I really dont think Arkham Asylum should be there though. Yea that part was amazing but to me its not really a cutscene |
|

Forum Posts: 361 | Comment #42 by Justin Case Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 10:07:51 AM | |
| Past two list has been very well chosen. I love it |
|

Forum Posts: 1060 | Comment #43 by CaptainSpanner Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 10:32:30 AM | |
| Agreed. MW2 deserved it. |
|

Forum Posts: 258 | Comment #44 by THC BLUNTED Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 10:36:39 AM | |
| Personally I think 1 and 2 should be swapped. I thought the halo wars cutscene was a lot better. |
|

Forum Posts: 214 | Comment #45 by xGoRmSx Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 10:45:32 AM | |
| No way! HALO WARS SO WAS MUCH BETTER!! *sad face* |
|

Forum Posts: 711 | Comment #46 by IceKingz Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 02:13:57 PM | |
| I was so mad at the MW2 cutscene. Gaz was my fav character of MW then Ghost came along and I was like 'he's the same VA, amazing mask, he can't possibly die as well' ....he died. Thanks IW, FOR TOYING WITH MY EMOTIONS!! |
|

Forum Posts: 238 | Comment #47 by SuperWoody64 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 02:33:02 PM | |
| I'm with number 4. As much as I love RE5 I don't think it, or 4 for that matter, deserve a number. They're more like spinoffs. |
|

Forum Posts: 1 | Comment #48 by Wolfofthewind Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 02:36:54 PM | |
Hahaha, I felt bad for Roach/Ghost, but I can't say I didn't see the betrayal coming. It was impending, Shepherd's personality was very fitting for the role. Not to mention the whole "danger close" issue, and the way he handled a lot of the scenarios. Also the incident with the CIA agent in the airliner? That's a perfect way to initiate the war he wanted, no? @46, haha! I had a bad feeling Ghost was prolly screwed, just because of that same VA. |
|

Forum Posts: 61 | Comment #49 by dcif20 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 04:51:08 PM | |
| i laughed during the whole mw2 cutscene |
|

Forum Posts: 102 | Comment #50 by N00B EATA Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 05:21:26 PM | |
you can call me whatever you want, but i have to admit i actually cried when ghost got shot. RIP GHOST |
|

Forum Posts: 86 | Comment #51 by zr122 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 06:16:17 PM | |
It's weird hearing people say "damn you Shepard!" when all I've been reading for the past two weeks has been ME2 tidbits. Great list, only played one of the games on it, but very well done. |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #52 by Calmed Fury Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 06:22:18 PM | |
| does anyone know if you can buy the CODMW2 soundtrack anywhere? I've been looking for it, but it's not even on iTunes.... |
|

Forum Posts: 203 | Comment #53 by samjustsam Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 07:02:22 PM | |
| man i think that arkham asylum scene should have won. im sick of hearing about halo anything. and modern warfare is good but that arkham asylum scene is just awesomeness. |
|

Forum Posts: 1714 | Comment #54 by UNDERWALLY Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 07:57:03 PM | |
Terrible list :( The best cutscene by far is the ending from MW2,with the knife and all, it make me wet my pants. Ghostbusters the videogame, had lots of cool cutscences too, and why the love for Halo Wars, that game sucks, and it's cutscenes are confusing and stupid |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #55 by Specter1000 Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 09:18:11 PM | |
| Halo Wars got a well deserved spot probably one of the best cut scenes in any halo game. |
|

Forum Posts: 252 | Comment #56 by Wulfaur Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 10:36:57 PM | |
| Halo Wars should have taken number 1. I remember me and my friends playing co-op and at that point we were like, "Oh Shit, those Spartans are raping." Halo Wars had some good cutscenes. I think Modern Warfare was very, (Cue Geese) Predictabo with its story, betrayals and cutscenes. |
|

Forum Posts: 407 | Comment #57 by KingSigy Wednesday, December 23, 2009 @ 10:46:39 PM | |
| I don't know about anything in MW2. The singleplayer was rather weak, in my opinion. I also didn't much care for Batman. |
|

Forum Posts: 301 | Comment #58 by toonsage Thursday, December 24, 2009 @ 12:08:22 AM | |
| that never happened to my 360 when i played batman o.o so odd...awesome list webyy =D |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #59 by Rirakku Thursday, December 24, 2009 @ 01:06:40 AM | |
| Eh, list was eh. I felt some bias in MW 2, everybody seems to love that game |
|

Forum Posts: 59 | Comment #60 by Gearbolt Thursday, December 24, 2009 @ 05:10:20 AM | |
| Batman should be #1, otherwise good list. |
|

Forum Posts: 173 | Comment #61 by Blue Thunder28 Thursday, December 24, 2009 @ 05:15:32 AM | |
| Good list. I loved the Batman cutscene the most... though I never got scared, the entire time I was loving how fucking sweet it was. |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #62 by dR PowerDrain Thursday, December 24, 2009 @ 09:13:04 AM | |
| You guys are good at this! Perfect Choices |
|

Forum Posts: 261 | Comment #63 by Madmax410 Thursday, December 24, 2009 @ 01:39:07 PM | |
I knew MW2 was going to get a spot. IMO the final cutscene was better, but still, this one was a good choice. Although I agree with some other users, after the twentieth scripted player death it was getting a little dull, lol |
|

Forum Posts: 9 | Comment #64 by JamMastrHibbert Thursday, December 24, 2009 @ 08:39:27 PM | |
| The only game on this list that I have played was batman. But I think the cutscene that should have made the top was halo wars, that was epic |
|

Forum Posts: 644 | Comment #65 by Munsie Friday, December 25, 2009 @ 09:27:36 AM | |
| Decent list but I personally think #1 and #2 are in the wrong order. |
|

Forum Posts: 43 | Comment #66 by BlO0DJUNKi3 Friday, December 25, 2009 @ 08:55:59 PM | |
| Yeah Halo Wars felt best to me but great list |
|

Forum Posts: 132 | Comment #67 by SuperchargedNL Saturday, December 26, 2009 @ 07:02:27 AM | |
| Great list! The Scarecrow cut-scene really made me look at my 360 to see if it didn't red ring at the time... :P |
|

Forum Posts: 2 | Comment #68 by Buzz Killer81 Saturday, December 26, 2009 @ 10:10:09 AM | |
| Haha the Arkham Asylum cutsceen should've been #1. I played both games and Modern Warfare 2 was a better game compaired to AA, and the cutsceen with Shepards betrayal was epic and emotional, but when you have a cutsceen that people react to and shut their console off because the gamer thinks it's frozen, that alone should be the reason for it's #1 spot. I almost shut down my console but then I remembered "Fission Mailed" from Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty, so I let it run. Haha glad I did. And the Halo franchise sucks my balls, period! Anytime we see Halo nominated for anything it's only because it's Halo!And that's a fact! The series has offered nothing revolutionary since health recharge in the 1st Halo. |
|

Forum Posts: 467 | Comment #69 by NawtyCawty Sunday, December 27, 2009 @ 03:34:58 PM | |
| I must admit I personaslly cant stand cutscenes, and really cant see the point of them. Its a game ffs not a film. They just get in the way of the gaming fun (and are usually shit anyway), please no more cutscenes - ever! |
|

Forum Posts: 68 | Comment #70 by STZ513 Sunday, December 27, 2009 @ 07:52:33 PM | |
@ anyone who thinks MW2 shouldn't get #1. It is one of the most emotional scenes of any game i've ever played. Halo Wars had an ending similar to that of about a hundred action movies. Yeah it was cool, but it really wasn't original, or did it draw out the emotions like MW2 did. As for AA, I was about to turn my console off then I was like "why is the moon a frowney face?" And @69 Just. wow. I love playing games with nothing to motivate me (not). A story gets the player more involved, hence getting them more motivated to play. (like achievements/ unlockable in-game rewards) |
|

Forum Posts: 73 | Comment #71 by LoveAsThouWilt Wednesday, December 30, 2009 @ 01:32:36 PM | |
See, I don't understand. Not likeing cutscenes that is. I have a friend that is the same way and what makes even the least since is that she doesn't like them AND likes RPGS more than anything else. Can you imagine an RPG without any cutscenes? Cutscenes moves the story further and pulls you into the game. Games ARE the new movies. They are an interactive experience. Being a gung-ho shoot everything then stop playing kind of gamer sounds kind of boring to me, but if thats your style so be it. If a game has a terrible story, I won't play it. The experience has to be worth the effort, whether through an enjoyable story or easy achievements lol. Without the story there are no games! It would be like taking a back-step into the past of atari games; where all you had to do was go through a |
|

Forum Posts: 239 | Comment #72 by atomic viking54 Wednesday, December 30, 2009 @ 04:38:34 PM | |
good list. idk about #5 but still good |
|

Forum Posts: 0 | Comment #73 by divineDOOMLORD Wednesday, December 30, 2009 @ 09:35:10 PM | |
| why resident evil 5 is on this list is beyond me. |
|

Forum Posts: 162 | Comment #74 by Zarkykins Sunday, January 03, 2010 @ 07:07:54 AM | |
I thought the cutscene in Assasin's Creed 2 where he reunites with his uncle Mario deserved it a bit more than RE5. "It's-a-me! Mario!" |
|

Forum Posts: 809 | Comment #75 by i got squeezed Sunday, January 03, 2010 @ 08:29:03 PM | |
| Im deep into Mw2 story and the characters, I sheded a slight tear when he shot Ghost and Roach, damn bastard |
|

Forum Posts: 18 | Comment #76 by Grufalo Saturday, January 09, 2010 @ 09:39:02 AM | |
| Demise of ghost wonderful cut scen but i think the sniper scenen from resident evil 5 should have been on second place. |
|