I set all the AI reversals down and made it easier to reverse as a player and he still reversed an absurd amount, but at least I could reverse a few more reversals. His worst offense is that irish whipping is basically impossible as he constantly reverses it making Edge's signatures worthless so you may want to edit one of them to a standing grapple or a running one.
I did find once you drop him, start hitting with elbows from the top rope. You can hit a few (I think I averaged 3 or 4) and he rarely blocks it.
Still, it seems to mostly be luck and patience. More often than not, he'd just counter everything, hit his signature and casually exit.