I'm having a tough time deciding. My top 3 are Leon, Chris and Sherry.
I find Sherry to be most useful (for me anyway), but Chris has a nice loadout as well. Leon I love the costume, but I don't really like the alt. load out.
100% Retail: 21/68 ; 100% Arcade: 41/67
Most Recent: Clive Barker's Jericho / Scarygirl