I think it is. When I went to trade it in at EB Games, the guy told me they have sold 2-3 pre-owned copies in the last 5-6 months. Either not many people have it, or they do and they don't trade it in.
I think it became more rare as time went on. It's a Rockstar game, so you know you are going to enjoy it one way or another.
Proud owner of the following threads:
EA Sports UFC - What Are You Expecting from EA?Thread
Dishonored - GOTY Edition Coming
Xbox One - *Last* Chance for Day One Editions Via Amazon
That last one means a lot to me, so please rate it 5 stars.