360 vs ps3?

[KingGotenW]

http://www.xbox360achievements.org/news/news.php?id=427

in my oppinion 360 owns the ps3. i dont know why they even tried to compare the 2 when it was obvious the 360 would win...

i may be biased. so you guys tell me which one you think has better quality graphics

[Minty]

Got to agree, I think the 360 looks better

[Whistler]

hmm PS3 version is smoother and less blocky then the 360. But 360 has better kontrast. But think you can get better kontrast then in that clip by tweeking tv or game settings so because of that and the more blocky screens I go with the PS3 ver.

[SegaSaturnSNK]

360 looks better but if they took time on the PS3, PS3 would of looked way better.

[PerpetualHeaven]

It's tight but I think the PS3 version slightly looks better in some instances but so does the 360. It's a tie for me. They both have equal faults in certain sections.

[Tom19]

360 FTW. Mainly because the 360 has achievements (not sure if PS3 has anything like this) but thats the main reason, plus i love the 360 and im not a Playstation fan anymore.

[hopesfall2win]

hmm PS3 version is smoother and less blocky then the 360. But 360 has better kontrast. But think you can get better kontrast then in that clip by tweeking tv or game settings so because of that and the more blocky screens I go with the PS3 ver.

There are articles that say the Ps3's framerate is less than the 360's. Here's one from a site where the editors are basically Ps3 fanboys.

http://news.softpedia.com/news/Bad-Frame-Rates-for-PS3-Assassin-039-s-Creed-70863.shtml

[twostepGARRETT]

the smoke effects on the 360 look sterile. but overall the 360 looks amazing. havent really seen the gameplay on the ps3.

[MrEastSide]

This is a 360 board. Which system did you think would be most favored? lol! Anyway, I won't vote since I haven't played the PS3 version. Maybe after I watch a few videos I'll be able to tell. But, according to most websites each version has their pluses and minuses.

[WeeChrissy360]

the 360 can grab the ps3 by the throat and slap it around with a wet fish until it dies

[Whistler]

360 FTW. Mainly because the 360 has achievements (not sure if PS3 has anything like this) but thats the main reason, plus i love the 360 and im not a Playstation fan anymore.

Yeah achievements sure makes the graphics look better ;)

[highpass]

Oh come on lads, they're almost bloody identical minus the odd bit of tearing. Textures are the same as far as i know, both apparently suffer from the odd frame drop, all the poly counts are identical, AA is the same... the PS3 capture seems to be suffering from a higher contrast or some such, probably more to do with the lads capturing rather than the native output itself but i could be wrong.

A slight difference, sure, but if anyone goes so far as to say the 360 version looks INSANELY BESTER i'll have to roffle.

The only things differentiating the two games in my opinion are achievements and the controller, both of which the 360 obviously wins.

Now, if you were comparing texture quality between the COD4 releases, that'd be a different matter altogether...

[Gorjira]

360 has achievements. Therefore pwns ps3 wthin all aspects.

[alpha305]

mos def the 360. Even though ps3 has the fancy cell processor and bluray capablilty It still has not made any impressive games to date. They look ok but not up to the standards that 360 has.

[BackerMan]

wow the 360 on assassin's creed look a lot better than ps3 verison.

[viciousmental56]

i think the 360 looks better
like when they zoomed in on his face i couldnt make out his eye on the PS3 but i could see in fine on the 360
the picture on the PS3 seemed foggy or fuzzy to me, that could be the contrast or something

[CaptainKicker]

360 do allways own Ps3!

[KingGotenW]

it appears that 360 wins in a land slide... (no surprise) 360 dominates the ps3.


p.s. twostepGARRETT (http://www.xbox360achievements.org/forum/member.php?u=38582) wtf is up with your avatar? didn't know the site allowed that...



360 :uzi: ps3 :(:(
:AR15:boom :(:(

[dark666]

Ok here is a copy paste and you can read it here http://kotaku.com/gaming/buyer-beware/assassins-creed-for-ps3-seeing-lock-ups-white-screen-of-death-323895.php


Irate PlayStation 3 owners are reporting a host of technical problems with their copies of Ubisoft's Assassin's Creed, writing of frame rate problems, screen tearing, geometry clipping and game-stopping lock ups on the official game forums. Most reports from those affected by "white screens of death" are writing that they're using firmware 2.0, specifying so at the request of official Ubisoft forum managers. In addition to a thread dedicated to the PS3's freezing issues, a consolidated bug/glitch thread is currently receiving plenty of responses. Similar postings have appeared on the official PlayStation 3 and Gamespot forums, with a few Kotaku tipsters warning us of the game's graphical and loading glitches. We're waiting to hear further information from Ubisoft, but would urge caution and research for potential Assassin's Creed buyers.

[twelve]

mos def the 360. Even though ps3 has the fancy cell processor and bluray capablilty It still has not made any impressive games to date. They look ok but not up to the standards that 360 has.
Clearly you haven't played Warhawk or Ratchet and Clank then.

Ratchet and Clank exceeds every platformer that has been released on the 360 (which isn't many :(). And Warhawk is definitely up to 360 standards, its nothing groundbreaking but it sure is fun.

As far as Assassins Creed goes, I'm swaying towards the PS3. I've heard a few reports that the 360 looks better but the game runs a few frames per second quicker on PS3 (then again there are some reports that say the opposite). I'll take whichever it runs better on, it's going to be graphically stunning on either system. If I hadn't imported a Dual Shock 3 then the 360 would have had an advantage due to rumble.

TBH tho I wouldn't use this poll to base the decision on at all. It's going to have a huge bias due to this being a 360 site and only a handful of people here actually have a PS3 as well as 360.

[roy1751]

The Achievement Unlocked popup is much higher resolution on the 360... ;)

But seriously the PS3 is apparently having some lockup issues with this game
http://kotaku.com/gaming/buyer-beware/assassins-creed-for-ps3-seeing-lock-ups-white-screen-of-death-323895.php

[Spartan EXR]

I havent compared, but Ill vote for 360 anyway....... This is a 360 forum after all!

[Zef]

The 360 version hands down. Why? Because it isn't the PS3 version =)

The real question here is whether Munty prefers the 360 version of Ms.Raymond or the PS3 version. Phone lines are open until midnight tonight!

[antnie]

Why would you say ps3 they could have done so much more but they did not.
360 owns

[zI HURRIC4N3 Iz]

Well, obviously i'm going to say 360.

[xboxman96]

360 by far, because the PS3 graphics look a little dull at times and the 360's are crisp and clear.

[AbOuT27nInJaS]

Ps3's really wank, all you get is shitty trophys and a banana for a controller. Plus the 360 looks alot sharper to me and the only good games on ps3 are ninja gaiden sigma and the new metal gear solid when it comes out. What an overpriced pile of crap.

[xfrearsx]

360 Kicks Playstation 3's "ASS" on so many levels there just is no comparison, and i don't just mean the way this game looks. (barring blueray that is!.)

[Rewmac]

Seen the video which compares the game on the two platforms. Seen about 5 of those videos and Assassin's Creed clearly looks better on the 360.

[dark666]

ok so you tell me that over all Ratchet and Clank is better than Bio Shock, Gears of Wars and Mass Effect keep you child games child. PS I have PS3 and I play my Wii more. The PS3 has what 3 good games and that is it I am a gamer I like to play games not stare at my Ps3 for weeks without nothing to play.

[Minty]

The 360 version hands down. Why? Because it isn't the PS3 version =)

The real question here is whether Munty prefers the 360 version of Ms.Raymond or the PS3 version. Phone lines are open until midnight tonight!

Well, missed the phone in....

Well I khave the 360 in the bedroom where as the PS3 is in the spare room, so gonna have to go with the 360 version.

And can I just say to the people that have gone 'OMFG the 360 pwns the ps3 on everything'. Stop being a fanboy. The 360 wins on some, the PS3 on others. If you cant stand up and admit when the console is beaten, then theres no need for developers to push to get more out of the console.

Fanboys are as bad as gamesavers.

[o BL4D3 o]

360 is slightly better i think

[Kif]

Does it even matter? They are both the same game. Did we even have these arguments in the last generation?

[rx32degrepber]

i also agree that the 360 i blowing away the ps3 bc all the games that were just for the ps3 are now coming to the 360

[The Fonz]

I go with 360 cause i like the look of it better

[templargunman]

ps3 has better graphics because it has a better graphics card, simple as that. The 360 is a better console (for one, it actually has a lot of games), but ps3 just pumped up the GC way over what it needed.

[highpass]

Er, what? Have you even compared the specs between the RSX and the Xenos?

The PS3 has a better CPU on paper, GPU not so much.

[templargunman]

Er, what? Have you even compared the specs between the RSX and the Xenos?

The PS3 has a better CPU on paper, GPU not so much.
No, I haven't, I don't spend my time comparing console graphics, this is just what I heard.

[highpass]

I don't spend my time comparing console graphics, this is just what I heard.

So no offense but you don't bother researching, yet feel quite happy saying things as if they're proven fact... There are enough people on the net that do spend their time comparing these things, i suggest you read up next time and make up your own mind rather than listen to word of mouth (as nine times out of ten you'll only get a fanboyish view anyway).

[templargunman]

ok, I'll do that, here's a fact, your over-reacting. I did some research (read your post), and I have come to the conclusion that you are not only over-reacting, but that I really don't care.

[highpass]

That's amazing, thanks for sharing your incredible views with us!

[Deyankees1]

havent you guys seen the comparison video 360 hands down

[templargunman]

That's amazing, thanks for sharing your incredible views with us!

Your welcome! Except those were facts, not views, and I have a new one, you're not over-reacting anymore.

havent you guys seen the comparison video 360 hands down

no, I haven't, that would probably help, I guess I was too busy playing to go research. (that wasn't another argument starter, as soon as I got it I played for 5 hours straight).

[Deyankees1]

incase u havent


http://www.gametrailers.com/player/28005.html

[highpass]

Actually, it was your view that I was over-reacting. In actual fact I was merely trying to help you not look so silly when you copy/paste other peoples opinions in future. Indeed, it is odd you don't care for such comparisons yet feel obliged to post in such threads.

[templargunman]

incase u havent

Thank you, 360 has better shadows, ps3 has better frame rate, now I see.

Actually, it was your view that I was over-reacting. In actual fact I was merely trying to help you not look so silly when you copy/paste other peoples opinions in future. Indeed, it is odd you don't care for such comparisons yet feel obliged to post in such threads.

I'm going to shut up in a sec because I'm eventually going to get myself banned, but I posted because it was a poll, it is my creed to post in all polls (did you catch the AC reference? Didjya?), so I will continue to even if the choices are: are you a jerk or are you stupid? Ok, done arguing.

[Deyankees1]

guys lets all get along. no need to argue. :)

[highpass]

You won't get banned for that kind of banter, hardly worthy of even an infraction to be honest. Carry on polling, nothing wrong with that...

Anyway, all that crap aside, both versions apparently suffer from framerate drops. Quite a few PS3 users have complained about lockups happening more often than are acceptable, although that may be due to the OS' news ticker running in the background.

[templargunman]

ok, I found another fact, 90... 100% of hamburgers are made from rocks. It's true!!!!:Bounce:

[narwak]

well i msu say that from all ym gaming in the past... XBOX will always rule.. who cares if it over heats and that shit... look at all the games that are coming for the 360.. and then look at the ps3 and the games coming for it.... and who gives a crap for blue ay... high def all the way!!! ... also if anyones interested msg narwak if intereseted in clan battles in gears/ halo 3 or u want to be recruted

[Ninjakb213]

I like the 360 and the ps3 i still think the ps3 is better :p

[templargunman]

I would say that according to the poll the 360 is better, except we're on a site with a big 360 in the header, so I'll instead say that the 360 is popular among 360 users.

[chenry]

Hmmm maybe this poll is biased lol

[she haunts me]

Hmmm maybe this poll is biased lol

agreed this is a website for the 360....we are a 360 commnity not PS3

[W. Samuel Jones III]

Of the people that voted I would would like to know how many own both systems.

I own a PS3 and 360 and if you have a high def tv and the HDMI cables there really is little difference in the graphics. The game trailer video isn't the same as viewing the game on a Sony Bravia 42" High Def TV.

It really is all subjective.

[Alliedknight]

Not only are the graphics better but the online is better compared to the 360 ps3s online is like two cans and a string deep in the forest.