Rate my gamercard

[excessum01]

So, I just made my first one and was hoping you'd give me feedback.

1-5, 5 being awesome and 1 being totally gay.

[Fonkey Monkey]

a 5 because thats the only hockey team i like!

[Norad45]

Im giving you a 5 as well....GO WINGS!:locked

[BlaZiN cdn]

4 because i dont really like the red wings:p

[excessum01]

Red Wings = #1 forever.

Stanley Cup champs 06-07!!! :woop: :woop:

[IMportdreams95]

How about you judge him on the card, not the team.

I'm also new at making cards, and i've give you a 3.. Im sure you'll get better. Not so sure i will rofl. :p

[The Pants Party]

The card is a bit disjointed. The things you want people to look at (i.e. your score, games played, rating, etc.) should be framed by the rest of the objects on the card. Move Stevie to the left, then stack the words "detroit, red, wings" on top of each other with the logo next to that on the right, and put everything else in the middle.

Look at Norad45's for what I mean by framing. The players to the left and right, the helmet on the bottom, then all the information in the middle. Yours is kind of scatterbrained.

[excessum01]

http://my.livecard.net/38542/shizelbs.png




2nd try. Comments?

[PerpetualHeaven]

I rated it a 4 it would have been a five. Very unique design, looks awesome. Only beef it looks pretty small. If you make it bigger, I think it deserves a 5.

[Mingledon]

Your first one is pretty average, it distracts from the main stuff and that is bad.

The second one is not my style, but I would give it a 3 too, since it is too bright and also too distracting.

[Maka]

I give it a 4 out of 5.

Brutal Honest!
Shirt-No-Eric

[excessum01]

What is Shirt-No-Eric?


By the way I changed it to how shizelbs wanted it.

http://my.livecard.net/38585/shizelbs.png

[Shizelbs]

I give your first one a 4 only because mine is better.

[excessum01]

Who gave it a one? You can't vote on an extreme end and not give an explanation...